Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by PolishKing
Raw
Avatar of PolishKing

PolishKing Kebab Remover

Member Seen 8 yrs ago

If I may take this off topic a bit can someone (Duck or Alfhedil) please either tell me whats wrong with my app or if I'm accepted or not.
1x Like Like
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Alfhedil
Raw
Avatar of Alfhedil

Alfhedil What do you see Kaneda?

Member Seen 1 hr ago

Wow. Just.... Wow. Come the fuck on people, this is why the NRP section is a cesspit. Get off your bias, your grudges and whatever preconceived notions of "the best RP" it is you have, and try not to shit up yet another NRP. Mindlessly bickering over who has what grudge, or trying to foist some inane idea unto the GM and make yourself the victim only drags everyone else down.



@PolishKing I read over your app from top to bottom, and I'll say exactly what it is that bothers Duck, and it's something I noticed yet passed over. The military section reads a bit strong, with a pretty tight focus on showing how advanced the nation is militarily. Most of it I just apathied past, as it doesn't really pose a concern to me, and I know that sheer technological power doesn't equate to military victory in any sense. My only real concern is that you seem to have set yourself up as completely self-reliant when it comes to the fantasy-resource. I too have a technocracy type of nation, but leave them to be more reliant on the outside world for their resources. What's the fun in having wonderous technologies and such if you have absolutely no need to trade for the resources that power them and build relations with foreign countries? Furthermore, I think it sets a dangerous precedent for one person to say how they have "large reserves" of "x", as in the past I have seen multiple apps following such NS' which state mostly the same. Regardless of how amazing this resource is, it is finite(At least I think it is...) and so we can't all have large mines of it. In truth, I would prefer that no player nation have a large source of the resource, and instead leave it to NPC nations so as to see about fostering a greater narrative. Beyond that, I don't see this RP as a game to be won, and I sincerely hope that no one else is here under that assumption. If you are, get out and go one section lower or two sections higher. Arena or Table-top games will be more suitable to you, and probably more welcoming to the attitude of who has the bigger e-penis.
3x Like Like
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by PolishKing
Raw
Avatar of PolishKing

PolishKing Kebab Remover

Member Seen 8 yrs ago

Wow. Just.... Wow. Come the fuck on people, this is why the NRP section is a cesspit. Get off your bias, your grudges and whatever preconceived notions of "the best RP" it is you have, and try not to shit up yet another NRP. Mindlessly bickering over who has what grudge, or trying to foist some inane idea unto the GM and make yourself the victim only drags everyone else down.



@PolishKing I read over your app from top to bottom, and I'll say exactly what it is that bothers Duck, and it's something I noticed yet passed over. The military section reads a bit strong, with a pretty tight focus on showing how advanced the nation is militarily. Most of it I just apathied past, as it doesn't really pose a concern to me, and I know that sheer technological power doesn't equate to military victory in any sense. My only real concern is that you seem to have set yourself up as completely self-reliant when it comes to the fantasy-resource. I too have a technocracy type of nation, but leave them to be more reliant on the outside world for their resources. What's the fun in having wonderous technologies and such if you have absolutely no need to trade for the resources that power them and build relations with foreign countries? Furthermore, I think it sets a dangerous precedent for one person to say how they have "large reserves" of "x", as in the past I have seen multiple apps following such NS' which state mostly the same. Regardless of how amazing this resource is, it is finite(At least I think it is...) and so we can't all have large mines of it. In truth, I would prefer that no player nation have a large source of the resource, and instead leave it to NPC nations so as to see about fostering a greater narrative. Beyond that, I don't see this RP as a game to be won, and I sincerely hope that no one else is here under that assumption. If you are, get out and go one section lower or two sections higher. Arena or Table-top games will be more suitable to you, and probably more welcoming to the attitude of who has the bigger e-penis.


Thank you for telling me what is wrong, I just wrote that up with my military because I had nothing to think of (In my opinion the military section should be the smallest section if if it has to be there at all) and that was the only thing I could think of.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Alfhedil
Raw
Avatar of Alfhedil

Alfhedil What do you see Kaneda?

Member Seen 1 hr ago

<Snipped quote by Alfhedil>

Thank you for telling me what is wrong, I just wrote that up with my military because I had nothing to think of (In my opinion the military section should be the smallest section if if it has to be there at all) and that was the only thing I could think of.


Eh, like I said it wasn't really that big of a sticking point to me. I've distanced myself from the school of thought where the player with the best toys and biggest most awesome military is the top dog. It gets old, and I do like that you've stuck to your principle there. One thing that I like to do, and that I actually picked up from an old RP partner, is to avoid absolutes when describing anything about your nation. Things like "the most" and such, it leaves more room for other people to stand beside you, rather than below or above you. All in all, it's a solid app in my opinion with only a few little things that stand out to me personally.
1x Like Like
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by PolishKing
Raw
Avatar of PolishKing

PolishKing Kebab Remover

Member Seen 8 yrs ago

<Snipped quote by PolishKing>

Eh, like I said it wasn't really that big of a sticking point to me. I've distanced myself from the school of thought where the player with the best toys and biggest most awesome military is the top dog. It gets old, and I do like that you've stuck to your principle there. One thing that I like to do, and that I actually picked up from an old RP partner, is to avoid absolutes when describing anything about your nation. Things like "the most" and such, it leaves more room for other people to stand beside you, rather than below or above you. All in all, it's a solid app in my opinion with only a few little things that stand out to me personally.


Just one final question, am I accepted or not?
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by MrFoxNews
Raw
Avatar of MrFoxNews

MrFoxNews The Boss

Member Seen 5 yrs ago

I'd just really love to get through an RP without it depending into the same bickering I've seen for over a year now.

Duck while I think you are a great roleplayer you need to seriously work on your people skills.
You think out of your mouth sometimes and that's not how a GM should act when talking to a possible player.
2x Like Like
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Opposition
Raw
Avatar of Opposition

Opposition π•‹π•–π•”π•™π•Ÿπ• π•π• π•˜π•šπ•”π•’π• π•Šπ•šπ•Ÿπ•˜π•¦π•π•’π•£π•šπ•₯π•ͺ

Member Seen 5 mos ago

I'd love to hop into this RP and I can have an app up relatively soon. I've not decided yet, but I'd love to take some land in Northern Pseudo-Africa if there's no problem with that.
Hidden 9 yrs ago 9 yrs ago Post by Willy Vereb
Raw
Avatar of Willy Vereb

Willy Vereb The Wordy Engineer

Member Seen 4 days ago

Alright everyone, mellow yer' mammaries. I've got opinions regarding Duck too, and I also have opinions regarding the situation. Personally I think that Duck is being overly hostile, and letting grudges control his actions. Whoop-de-doo. Now can we just move what is quickly becoming a heated argument over into a PM, and leave the OOC for focusing on the RP itself? It's these kinds of arguments that always plague these kinds of roleplays, and I tend to peg them with killing it off. So please, let's just calm down in here. I'll even make PM for y'all to argue in, but arguing over who holds a grudge or not isn't related to the RP.

Please, can we not screw this one up?
Reposting for emphasis.
I made the point about not continuing such an argument to prevent this from clogging up the OOC. Especially when I apparently don't even participate in it.
If somebody is dissatisfied with the way things are and think I would spinelessly turn away from this argument with a sense of faux victory... just hit me up in PMs and I tend to you. I refuse to make further comments in this thread for the sake of avoiding to ruin this game, nothing else.

For the record I have no beef against Duck and wish the feelings would be mutual. Regardless, I said what I did say. No changing it and I wish if Duck does consider them a bit.

Anyways, if we are at steampunk I quickl suggest a change of topic. What kind of steampunk techs everyone came up with? It's sharing time!

I read over your app from top to bottom, and I'll say exactly what it is that bothers Duck, and it's something I noticed yet passed over. The military section reads a bit strong, with a pretty tight focus on showing how advanced the nation is militarily. Most of it I just apathied past, as it doesn't really pose a concern to me, and I know that sheer technological power doesn't equate to military victory in any sense. My only real concern is that you seem to have set yourself up as completely self-reliant when it comes to the fantasy-resource. I too have a technocracy type of nation, but leave them to be more reliant on the outside world for their resources. What's the fun in having wonderous technologies and such if you have absolutely no need to trade for the resources that power them and build relations with foreign countries? Furthermore, I think it sets a dangerous precedent for one person to say how they have "large reserves" of "x", as in the past I have seen multiple apps following such NS' which state mostly the same. Regardless of how amazing this resource is, it is finite(At least I think it is...) and so we can't all have large mines of it. In truth, I would prefer that no player nation have a large source of the resource, and instead leave it to NPC nations so as to see about fostering a greater narrative. Beyond that, I don't see this RP as a game to be won, and I sincerely hope that no one else is here under that assumption.
Most resources being held by an NPC sounds like a fun intraction but only if the said NPC is controlled by the GMs.
Though I don't see large resource pool being a problem so long it doesn't lead to a "Mary Sueish" situation where your nation is the bestest because it can dominate anyone without any sorts of support.
Of course that's up for the GMs to regulate.
Players trading their resources sounds perhaps even more fun than doing it with NPCs.

Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by MrFoxNews
Raw
Avatar of MrFoxNews

MrFoxNews The Boss

Member Seen 5 yrs ago

I actually had a question regarding the America's, is it alright if we have some fantastical wildlife to hamper colonization efforts?

I was thinking giant killer worms or something of the sort alongside the Native humans.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by PolishKing
Raw
Avatar of PolishKing

PolishKing Kebab Remover

Member Seen 8 yrs ago

I actually had a question regarding the America's, is it alright if we have some fantastical wildlife to hamper colonization efforts?

I was thinking giant killer worms or something of the sort alongside the Native humans.


Mongolian Death Worms could be fun.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by null123
Raw
GM

null123

Member Seen 9 mos ago

I actually had a question regarding the America's, is it alright if we have some fantastical wildlife to hamper colonization efforts?

I was thinking giant killer worms or something of the sort alongside the Native humans.


I am going to say no. I want to limit the more fantastical elements to blue coal and the technology.

@Willy Vereb

If your not planning on joining, I rather you stay out of the OOC.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by gowia
Raw
Avatar of gowia

gowia Buried in a Book

Member Seen 1 yr ago



Want to get mine up so I have claimed my land and my intent to stay is known :)


Right my sheet is finished, can I please get some notes if I have anything that is wrong, and is not. Can I get some confirmation that I am in.
Hidden 9 yrs ago 9 yrs ago Post by null123
Raw
GM

null123

Member Seen 9 mos ago

And your fine.

Edit:If you get accepted, drop your app into the char tab.
1x Like Like
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Rhymer
Raw
Avatar of Rhymer

Rhymer Kuiper Belt Object

Member Seen 7 yrs ago

<Snipped quote by gowia>

Right my sheet is finished, can I please get some notes if I have anything that is wrong, and is not. Can I get some confirmation that I am in.


I'm confused. Is the Lancian Empire just a colony? Where is the Home Nation in Algaesia of the Lancian Empire? Also, The Matwe Confederation will have a vague notion of your hostility towards natives-nothing specific due to the distance between Lancia and Matwe proper.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by null123
Raw
GM

null123

Member Seen 9 mos ago

<Snipped quote by gowia>

I'm confused. Is the Lancian Empire just a colony? Where is the Home Nation in Algaesia of the Lancian Empire? Also, The Matwe Confederation will have a vague notion of your hostility towards natives-nothing specific due to the distance between Lancia and Matwe proper.


The Lancian Empire is the homeland/father nation(me). As part of a way of keeping the colony managed, it was later federated and put under the Provincial Duke. That is my understanding, anyways.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Rhymer
Raw
Avatar of Rhymer

Rhymer Kuiper Belt Object

Member Seen 7 yrs ago

<Snipped quote by Rhymer>

The Lancian Empire is the homeland/father nation(me). As part of a way of keeping the colony managed, it was later federated and put under the Provincial Duke. That is my understanding, anyways.


The empire is the colony?
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by null123
Raw
GM

null123

Member Seen 9 mos ago

No, the Archipelago itself is the colony.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Rhymer
Raw
Avatar of Rhymer

Rhymer Kuiper Belt Object

Member Seen 7 yrs ago

No, the Archipelago itself is the colony.


Then where did the colonists come from? A colony has to have a nation of origin. I don't see it on the map.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by PolishKing
Raw
Avatar of PolishKing

PolishKing Kebab Remover

Member Seen 8 yrs ago

<Snipped quote by duck55223>

Then where did the colonists come from? A colony has to have a nation of origin. I don't see it on the map.


The colonists came from Ducks nation
The one in Germany.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Rhymer
Raw
Avatar of Rhymer

Rhymer Kuiper Belt Object

Member Seen 7 yrs ago

<Snipped quote by Rhymer>

The colonists came from Ducks nation
The one in Germany.


Ah well that is making so much more sense. I didn't see ducks nation yet. Thanks for clearing that up. I thought I was crazy for a minute.
↑ Top
© 2007-2024
BBCode Cheatsheet