No yeah, lets keep the feelings in the IC guys.
I actually really like the challenge, to be honest.
Both are in the wrong here. Silvern is clearly doing a power play and others are going to fall for it(see Gillian). Its a hard sell to put your faith in someone many would see as a kid, and any minor mistake is going to get blown out of proportion.
That said, Tyaethe is the voice of the super conservative members. So, even if outside the order this would seem like a bad idea, She's unlikely to change her opinion over night (if ever). Fanlily will always be the exception for her, and thats great! That she can trust someone that much speaks a lot to her character, and fighting for it doubly so.
So lets just take a step back and pet the hundi.
Uh, there's at least... well, two things in that post that are probably bad ideas (one because it's notably false, the other because... uh...)
The first one is that... Tyaethe
does do stuff. A lot. That is, guarding the captain with completely suicidal behaviour. That part's just confusing (slightly more than Gillian's glorious ability to misunderstand what she says every time) O_o
But the other thing is, uh...
Not because some dusty corpse tells me I should because she was born under a good moon.”
... In terms of bad things to say, insulting the saint that founded the order (or the high priestess that chose the succession, if it wasn't Elionne) so blatantly in front of a member of the church isn't something that I think can be roleplayed around without taking things in a... far more convoluted and conflict-filled direction than is wanted.
I mean, even Julianna's close to the church. That just seems a horrific thing to say.