Plenty of other RPs for that sort of thing. In a RP where the aim is to *hunt monsters* and *play heroes*, doing so kind of misses the point.
And given the tone and setting are supposed to be serious and not without grit, I just can't see a Sonic "Original Character"TM cyclopess jiving.
I was going to turn her human like, as I do with many of my concepts. I didn't want her to be in her Sonic FC version here. Polyphema is based off the cyclops Polyphemus in the Odyssey. She doesn't have an anthro animal species, I based her off of the Classic Greek poem.
Still, if there's no decent villain or antagonist here I feel that's a shame. The Greek Gods were very tragic figures and not everyone of them were 100% good or 100% evil themselves, even Hades could be reasonable every so often and Zeus was sort of a dick. Greek mythos is NOT hero saves the day, it's very tragic and filled with moral grey figures.