Put that way it is at least better, yes. Still eh on the concept itself, but we'll see.
What's the worst that can happen? The way I see it, Jason's nobody's favorite hero or Anti-Hero, he's considered by some to be a decent villain, and most would have him be just that, a villain. Bruce's biggest mistake. (After Damian, piece of shit, but that one's just imo.) Therefor, he's certainly the safest out of all of the Birdboys to turn into something different than he was original. I wanna make him different from Bruce, or his canon counter-part, yet still similar to both.
Edit: Also, RE:Dick being a cop, we have quite a lot of cops. That should be pretty interesting.