@Dusksong But my point is that if it were a class, the students would have very little choice in whether they stayed or not. I mean, at least in my school, you couldn't drop your elected classes. If it were an after-school group there's the chance that the students won't show up or won't care about showing up because it's after school and on weekends, plus considering they may have jobs and such, it wouldn't be fair for the school to impose on their free time outside of school hours. Whereas if it were a class, most likely one that is on the last period, they'd have little choice if they cared about attendance and grades.
Plus there is after school activities like Cheerleading, Debate Club, theater, student council, etc. to be in mind of. if this were another one, others may be missing out on their designated activities and I don't think a Principal would allow that of the students chosen.
But I also believe we need to suspend some belief on this. I am only stating what I feel on this. As in, I think if anything was to be done about it (i.e. parents suing, students quesioning) it would have been done already.
But idk for sure, I leave this up to our GMs
Plus there is after school activities like Cheerleading, Debate Club, theater, student council, etc. to be in mind of. if this were another one, others may be missing out on their designated activities and I don't think a Principal would allow that of the students chosen.
But I also believe we need to suspend some belief on this. I am only stating what I feel on this. As in, I think if anything was to be done about it (i.e. parents suing, students quesioning) it would have been done already.
But idk for sure, I leave this up to our GMs