Hidden 9 yrs ago 9 yrs ago Post by Vilageidiotx
Raw
Avatar of Vilageidiotx

Vilageidiotx Jacobin of All Trades

Member Seen 2 yrs ago

@Vilageidiotx Well he also sites his sources. And you didn't answer my question about air line food? Dammit the hard hitting questions must be answered. :P


yeh, but it's twenty minutes and you can't skim a video. plus i know i can't trust some young republican ray william johnson looking motherfucker.

Like I said, editorials are bad. Youtube is about as editorial as you can get. That's just one step above posting politically-charged memes. But if you like difficult links and want one that isn't editorial, lets try this.

A Report by the Canadian Government on public perceptions about healthcare.

I skimmed this. The pertinent bits are...

1: Canadians are against the idea of privatizing their healthcare, quite strongly opposed. 85% of Canadians asked thought that privatizing the Canadian system would change life in Canada, and 87% of those thing the change would be negative. That's roughly a quarter of Canadians polled who thinks that privatizing the healthcare system would be bad for Canada.

2: People don't like the waits times. This is the common complaint, and it's sensible. Like I said in the black/white discussion, I don't believe in perfect fixes, and I think everything is usually imperfect and can be made better. So obviously I don't think there are any absolutely perfect healthcare systems. I feel the need to point out the main reason those wait times don't exist in the United States is that Americans generally can't afford to be on the ball with their healthcare needs, even with insurance. We don't have lines because we can't afford to go to the hospital unless we have to. So whereas the wait in the socialized system is something that needs to be addressed, it's better than the inability to pay for access altogether.

As for airline food, I haven't flown for ten years and no matter how much I try, I can't find a fast food join that sells airplane food.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Frizan
Raw

Frizan Free From This Backwater Hellsite

Contest Mod Seen 2 yrs ago

It irks me when people post passive-aggressive comments about how what you're saying is wrong, but then refuse to elaborate on how you are wrong. Just saying "you're wrong" helps nobody. Not you, not the person you're saying is wrong, and not the people that will read what you've written. It just makes me think you have no actual factual basis for what you think and are just throwing half-hearted jabs at me because you can't actually refute what I'm saying.

No, this has no relation to anything said in this thread. It's just a general peeve of mine.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by TheEvanCat
Raw
Avatar of TheEvanCat

TheEvanCat Your Cool Alcoholic Uncle

Member Seen 3 mos ago

It irks me when people post passive-aggressive comments about how what you're saying is wrong, but then refuse to elaborate on how you are wrong. Just saying "you're wrong" helps nobody. Not you, not the person you're saying is wrong, and not the people that will read what you've written. It just makes me think you have no actual factual basis for what you think and are just throwing half-hearted jabs at me because you can't actually refute what I'm saying.

No, this has no relation to anything said in this thread. It's just a general peeve of mine.


You're wrong.
1x Laugh Laugh
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Vilageidiotx
Raw
Avatar of Vilageidiotx

Vilageidiotx Jacobin of All Trades

Member Seen 2 yrs ago

<Snipped quote by Frizan>

You're wrong.


no your wrong
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by SleepingSilence
Raw
Avatar of SleepingSilence

SleepingSilence OC, Plz No Stealz.

Member Seen 1 day ago

@Vilageidiotx Hmm...I wrote something...and it disappeared. (So best I got.) -.-
1. Not really
2. From 2007, and those stats offered really, really...don't mean anything.
3. I agree with healthcare system flawed, do not agree socialized care will help. (oh and since I promised. Wuff. <.<)

And you're all wrong! D:<
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Vilageidiotx
Raw
Avatar of Vilageidiotx

Vilageidiotx Jacobin of All Trades

Member Seen 2 yrs ago

@Vilageidiotx Hmm...I wrote something...and it disappeared. (So best I got.) -.-
1. Not really
2. From 2007, and those stats offered really, really...don't mean anything.
3. I agree with healthcare system flawed, do not agree socialized care will help. (oh and since I promised. Wuff. <.<)

And you're all wrong! D:<


This thing has died Down to the Point I Can post from my Phone. Basically, the 9 years that has passed has no reason to be a confounding issue in regards to what we are discussing.
Hidden 9 yrs ago 9 yrs ago Post by Sen
Raw
Avatar of Sen

Sen Outlier

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

@Vilageidiotx Hmm...I wrote something...and it disappeared. (So best I got.) -.-
1. Not really
2. From 2007, and those stats offered really, really...don't mean anything.

As a Canadian, 1 is actually a pretty popular opinion. If you go into the praries where it's ultra conservative, you'll find parties trying to advocate privitization, but that's again only the conservative conservatives. Pretty much nobody wants privitization here. 2 is also by far the biggest complaint. The wait times are really killer, especially outside of more doctor-y areas yet people keep wanting to lower taxes like the government can print out all the money they need. But I'd take wait times over crippling debt if I need medical care any day. I'm not sure about the exact stats, but the general point is very much true. Not much has changed here since 2007 imo.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Dinh AaronMk
Raw
Avatar of Dinh AaronMk

Dinh AaronMk my beloved (french coded)

Member Seen 6 days ago

<Snipped quote by SleepingSilence>

This thing has died Down to the Point I Can post from my Phone. Basically, the 9 years that has passed has no reason to be a confounding issue in regards to what we are discussing.


After all I don't think that opinion stats for a relatively unchanged system in Canada is going to mean much in nine-years. It's not like statistics for something like teen pregnancy where the percentages can change depending on how much you produce a constant and fresh Public Service campaign about it or how well you fund sex-education. Socialized healthcare would be for them something that's so fundamental the only immediate opinion changes might be whether or not its over or under-funded.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Vilageidiotx
Raw
Avatar of Vilageidiotx

Vilageidiotx Jacobin of All Trades

Member Seen 2 yrs ago

But I'd take wait times over crippling debt if I need medical care any day.


Here is a fun fact; my parents had to take a mortgage on their house to pay for my sister's surgery, and that was before Obama was president.

After all I don't think that opinion stats for a relatively unchanged system in Canada is going to mean much in nine-years. It's not like statistics for something like teen pregnancy where the percentages can change depending on how much you produce a constant and fresh Public Service campaign about it or how well you fund sex-education. Socialized healthcare would be for them something that's so fundamental the only immediate opinion changes might be whether or not its over or under-funded.


That is what I was thinking. I picked this study because it was just that - a study, no frills or people trying to prove anything. I couldn't think of any good confounds between then and now that would make this study inapplicable. The Canadian system isn't new, so you couldn't explain good will in 2007 as just being the new car smell. The only two things that could possibly confound it is a conservative government that was in power in Canada between those times, and the fact that healthcare has become such a major conversation in America. But both of those things if they were to have any effect should make their system more popular, not less.
Hidden 9 yrs ago 9 yrs ago Post by SleepingSilence
Raw
Avatar of SleepingSilence

SleepingSilence OC, Plz No Stealz.

Member Seen 1 day ago

@Vilageidiotx Well since posting evidence, or anything to prove my point is something I'm not suppose to do. I officially feel like I'm being quite unproductive in this discussion. -.- And a decade can provide quite a large chunk of difference, but even if not, people "thinking" something literally has nothing to do with how effective something is or isn't.

mises.ca/private-health-care-is-inevit.. (Though I doubt the title will actually happen anytime soon, this is just a little showing that USA isn't the only one with healthcare cost problems.)

I just think most people WANT socialized medicine because they here the word "Free Healthcare" and go OH BOY FREE STUFF! And it's not free...someone is paying for it.

@Sen I suppose since it was so short, my opinion wasn't clear. So I'll just say, I never thought Canadians secretly wanted to have privatization. Though I know a lot of them do not like how their care system is being run currently, just by many that I speak with.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Sen
Raw
Avatar of Sen

Sen Outlier

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

I just think most people WANT socialized medicine because they here the word "Free Healthcare" and go OH BOY FREE STUFF! And it's not free...someone is paying for it.

Yeah, but it doesn't actually cost much to have "free" health care for everyone compared to America's bills. It's payed indirectly from taxes (EI, income taxes, etc.), but that means it's also scaled by income. A poor family, who wouldn't normally afford health care, pay low taxes but get "free" health care. A rich family pays high taxes, even though they could just go private and get their own health care, but still gets the same health care. I think the stat came out to be an average of $4k a year for an adult? Families with dependants obviously pay more because children are just leaches but I digress.

also imo that blog looks pretty biased, but it's not wrong in some places

I suppose since it was so short, my opinion wasn't clear. So I'll just say, I never thought Canadians secretly wanted to have privatization. Though I know a lot of them do not like how their care system is being run currently, just by many that I speak with.

I again think most people are fine with the system itself, but if you mean they don't like how said system is managed, then yes, I agree. The problem comes mostly with how understaffed it is. Specialists and appointments take fooorreeevvveerrrr. I can't imagine just being able to walk into a doctor's office and getting a check-up. Obviously the ER isn't like that, but the concept of going to the doctor when your minorly sick is unthinkable. You'd get over your illness by the time you get in. Do Americans actually go to the doctor when they have a cold or the flu? Can you actually get a doctor's note for school?
Hidden 9 yrs ago 9 yrs ago Post by Vilageidiotx
Raw
Avatar of Vilageidiotx

Vilageidiotx Jacobin of All Trades

Member Seen 2 yrs ago

since posting evidence, or anything to prove my point is something I'm not suppose to do.


Oh come on now, be more gracious then that, nobody wants to talk to a salty libertarian. Youtubers aren't evidence. The problem with editorials is that they don't represent evidence, they represent another person making an argument. Those people might have evidence or they might not, but in a discussion like this throwing a bunch of editorials around is debate by attrition, especially when all you have to do is spend ten minutes finding more articles to throw at me. I don't have time to pour over four different articles, each one put together over the course of a longer time, and then to refute each one. Use evidence to back up claims surely, but if you are going to link something you are responsible for breaking down how that evidence is relevant and applying it to the discussion yourself. That's just how these things are done. I could have threw links willy nilly too and not explained my position, but that's not fun. This is supposed to be a brain exercise, man! It's not good enough to believe in a thing and dote helplessly on a few pundits, you gotta explain the guts of these things yourself. It's my opinion that if you can't defend the guts of a position yourself then shouldn't be publically supportive of it.

I just think most people WANT socialized medicine because they here the word "Free Healthcare" and go OH BOY FREE STUFF! And it's not free...someone is paying for it.


The problem with this argument (besides aristocratic overtones of "The peasants ask too much") is that economics isn't a zero sum game. Privatization is a byword to mean commodification, that's what we are talking about, and some things make piss-poor commodities. We all generally accept, for instance, that defense would make a piss poor commodity. When things go on the market, they become subject to the avarice of the market. Healthcare makes a poor commodity (or one reason at least) because the purchaser of healthcare is in a poor position to bargain. If you have cancer, you can't exactly decline from purchasing care. There was a decency to the traditional small town doctor, a man who would have been ran out of town on a rail if he had tried to overcharge, but who's abilities and equipment were ultimately limited, and who could be subjected easily to the competition that makes capitalism "function". But that age ended with technology and what amounts to the need for expensive capital to be a doctor in the modern world. There was an inevitability that the private healthcare system, through the inability of the public to bargain for their health, and through the conflict between insurance and the hospitals for the former to avoid paying out and the later to take as much as they can, that the commodification of healthcare would do what it did in the United States.

And it seems a little cruel to start threatening our Canadians friends with privatization. People need to sleep at night.

also imo that blog looks pretty biased, but it's not wrong in some places


The front page had an article about privatizing money. I believe I said something earlier about Austrian school being something that serious economists poke fun at even more than they do Marx? Well, this website declares itself Canada's leading Austrian economics educators. I was going to refute the article but there wasn't really anything to grab onto, since it is pretty much just a dude pointing to a chart and saying "Look guys, its scary, this is so many costs guys."

I again think most people are fine with the system itself, but if you mean they don't like how said system is managed, then yes, I agree. The problem comes mostly with how understaffed it is. Specialists and appointments take fooorreeevvveerrrr. I can't imagine just being able to walk into a doctor's office and getting a check-up. Obviously the ER isn't like that, but the concept of going to the doctor when your minorly sick is unthinkable. You'd get over your illness by the time you get in. Do Americans actually go to the doctor when they have a cold or the flu? Can you actually get a doctor's note for school?


Old people will go to the emergency room for a flu. In my experience, people usually go to cheap walk-in clinics to get doctors notes, since they are usually equipped for exactly those sort of trifling things. I don't know anybody who ever went to a doctor for a cold. It's rather American to brag about going to work while having a cold or a flu anyway.

I think the stat came out to be an average of $4k a year for an adult?


Imma go ahead and cut off at the pass any argument based on this and say that the US pays 8k per person for healthcare just in taxes. So that private system where we have to pay our bills and for insurance? That's also causing us to pay twice as much in taxes for healthcare than the Canadians do.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by SleepingSilence
Raw
Avatar of SleepingSilence

SleepingSilence OC, Plz No Stealz.

Member Seen 1 day ago

@Sen Based on my last link, Ontario Canada's healthcare is 50% percent of their budget...yeah it costs A LOT of money. Healthcare costs a shit load of money. It's just someone else paying for someone else...Well another problem is 47% of america doesn't pay any income tax...and our country is much, MUCH larger in population. And our bigger population does in fact make it a lot harder to make socialize medicine work. (35 to 318 million) So if the average is about 4k, just comparing to our population, our average would pay 36,000 a year. (9 times the population) Sound cheap? (that's just one way it's a bit different.) Also according to this is cost the average family 11 thousands...doesn't sound too cheap to me. ($141 billion on health care for Canada a year.)
ctvnews.ca/health/true-cost-of-health-..

The other link had something with Canada's healthcare system, he was born in Canada. And yes, America goes for check up's, even when they feel fine. Precisely why America has the best cancer prevention by a very large margin. A lot of illnesses screw you up, long before you feel any actual symptoms. But I digress.
Hidden 9 yrs ago 9 yrs ago Post by SleepingSilence
Raw
Avatar of SleepingSilence

SleepingSilence OC, Plz No Stealz.

Member Seen 1 day ago

@Vilageidiotx It wasn't the youtube videos that you mentioned. It was literally anything. Don't go lying now. X3 And salty? Are you sure your not secretly just being a very very bored troll? :P One step up from 'u mad bro?'

One of your posts, was a straw man argument about evil bigmart polluting the lake...and a WAY too long thing about trickle down economics (something that doesn't exist.) There is a reason, I posted links because I'm aware some people MIGHT know more about things than I do. And your feeding me a lot of b.s quite honestly...People that debate positions do not just look up every piece of evidence by themselves without siting sources, or providing more evidence. XP (or one step further. Doesn't do any damn research at all.)

I wasn't even bringing up Canada to say, they want privatization, I literally don't know how that started...>.> Which is why I said your stats meant nothing. Also it's not an overblown argument, people actually believe that by a depressingly large margin.

Also, at this point I swear your provoking so I keep this boring conversation up. -.-

Also, are you bringing up the average person pays 8,000 as negative thing? Or that it is actually not the case? I assume the former since your saying "We pay TWICE as much." Well under their system we'd be paying a lot more than that...just by average population. Because an absurd amount of people pay no real taxes, which may be another underline reason, why we have a larger bill. But as I already said, and won't get into it any farther because this is just pointless. I agree to disagree, on socialized medicine.

Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by TheEvanCat
Raw
Avatar of TheEvanCat

TheEvanCat Your Cool Alcoholic Uncle

Member Seen 3 mos ago

The trick to socialized healthcare is to set it up and then immediately work to institute a culture that stigmatizes anyone who goes to the doctor as a pussy. Write them negative reports at their job, have their peers judge them for weakness, and make sure that every boss suspects that their employee is trying to sham out. That way you keep costs and waiting times down because a million people won't go in for their sniffles.

They'll get over their respiratory infection or sprained wrist by sucking it up and eating over the counter Motrin like candy or drinking a fuckload of water, building character as they go. Alternatively, people learn basic medical skills and treat themselves and their buddies with household equipment.

Literally can't go wrong.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Sen
Raw
Avatar of Sen

Sen Outlier

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

So if the average is about 4k, just comparing to our population, our average would pay 36,000 a year.

I think I'm done with this conversation now that I said what I wanted to say, but I just want to know what kinda math this is. Why would it be times nine? Assuming everyone pays all their taxes, it would be the exact same, because each new person has to pay 4k, wouldn't it? Also the family one sounds bad, and for a single-income household sure (again, children are leaches) but if you look at the comments of people on that article, a lot of them say they pay a third of what they did/would in America. That's better to me.

I'm not trying to say Canada's healthcare is a perfect example everyone should copy, because it's very far from that, but it's financially better for taxpayers than America's system by a large margin.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by SleepingSilence
Raw
Avatar of SleepingSilence

SleepingSilence OC, Plz No Stealz.

Member Seen 1 day ago

@Sen Canada 35 mil people, USA has 318 mil. 9 times the population, just a rough assumption. It's likely going to be that in cost, OR even higher for the middle class/upper middle class, since a lot of the population doesn't pay taxes. I never meant to start a conversation with Canada anyway. I'd think I'd rather live there solely because everyone I've meant there is a nice human being. But I just find people here trying to say your healthcare is 'super free', is kind of insulting because how you guys kind of get the shaft. At least from what I've heard from my friends there.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Vilageidiotx
Raw
Avatar of Vilageidiotx

Vilageidiotx Jacobin of All Trades

Member Seen 2 yrs ago

I can't say much because I'm at work, but I can't say I appreciate the insinuation I'm a liar.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by SleepingSilence
Raw
Avatar of SleepingSilence

SleepingSilence OC, Plz No Stealz.

Member Seen 1 day ago

@Vilageidiotx Well what you said was wrong and misleading, but I apologize for being direct about it. I tried to add an emoticon to express sarcasm. But I guess it was missed. <.<
Hidden 9 yrs ago 9 yrs ago Post by Vilageidiotx
Raw
Avatar of Vilageidiotx

Vilageidiotx Jacobin of All Trades

Member Seen 2 yrs ago

Well, i'm back.

I feel everything has gotten a tad heated. I don't want there to be bad feelings or discomfort from this thing. We're all peasants in the end and there is no reason for us to build up any animosity over something we cannot control. Now, if you want to continue, I can probably tap out some refutations tomorrow, but if this is all too unpleasant, I'm willing to drop the thing at this time and let this thread back to bitching about SJW's.
↑ Top
© 2007-2024
BBCode Cheatsheet