In regards to the new logo, I personally liked the old one better. A big R for Roleplayer Guild made good sense and was unique. I can't say what other people think, though.

As a Graphic Designer, I can say the Guild's old logo stuck better. We'd already had it long enough--Changing it at this point, and for a completely different look nonetheless, seems like an unwise move.

There, my two cents as a professional ;)

<Snipped quote by BBeast>
<Snipped quote by Frettzo>
What logo are yall talking about?

I've made some logos for the guild years ago when I was just a wee lad, but they're gone and lost.

Before redpanda made an image for us today, all we had was some cold grey text that said Roleplayer Guild at the top of the site.

<Snipped quote by BBeast>
<Snipped quote by Frettzo>
What logo are yall talking about?

I've made some logos for the guild years ago when I was just a wee lad, but they're gone and lost. And quite shit, to be honest. So yall prob aren't talking about those.

Before redpanda made an image for us today, all we had was some cold grey text that said Roleplayer Guild at the top of the site. That the "logo" on yall's minds?

I like the new one, it looks way more professional than the last one. The notepad means that this site is about writing detailed posts, which makes sense.

<Snipped quote> It looks mind-numbingly generic. It's your typical notepad-sign for me.

It doesn't associate with roleplayerguild.com.
It associates with untitled.txt.

<Snipped quote by Shienvien>

It looks way better than just having the words 'Roleplayerguild' with no picture or nothing to go off of. You just have to deal with the new image.

<Snipped quote> It looks mind-numbingly generic. It's your typical notepad-sign for me.

It doesn't associate with roleplayerguild.com.
It associates with untitled.txt.