1 Guest viewing this page
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Lord Wraith
Raw
GM
Avatar of Lord Wraith

Lord Wraith Actually Three Otters in a Trenchcoat

Member Seen 41 min ago

I should probably ask this,

Would you guys appreciate a blurb on H.E.L.P./H.I.T., or is there any other Vigilance Info I can provide that would help out?
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Wade Wilson
Raw
Avatar of Wade Wilson

Wade Wilson bruh.

Member Seen 5 yrs ago

I should probably ask this,

Would you guys appreciate a blurb on H.E.L.P./H.I.T., or is there any other Vigilance Info I can provide that would help out?


Blurb on H.E.L.P./H.I.T., please.
Hidden 9 yrs ago 9 yrs ago Post by Nemaisare
Raw
Avatar of Nemaisare

Nemaisare

Member Seen 12 hrs ago

Coolio on the convoy front.

And a H.E.L.P./H.I.T. blurb would be awesome. Info is love. :P
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Lord Wraith
Raw
GM
Avatar of Lord Wraith

Lord Wraith Actually Three Otters in a Trenchcoat

Member Seen 41 min ago

H.E.L.P. and H.I.T. has been added to the OP.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Bigg Slamm
Raw
Avatar of Bigg Slamm

Bigg Slamm The Biggest Fish in the Sea

Member Seen 2 yrs ago

edits have also been made to my sheet here in the thread should anyone else like to peruse them.
1x Thank Thank
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Tyler
Raw
Avatar of Tyler

Tyler Me. I Am Tyler... / The Elusive Auteur

Member Seen 4 yrs ago

edits have also been made to my sheet here in the thread should anyone else like to peruse them.


I'm no authority in this RP by any means, but I'd like to offer up my opinion on your powerset, if that's okay:

Personally, I feel you have a good character who is let down by a powerset that I just can't quite seem to get onboard with. One of the various beauties of the Vigilance universe is the 'realism' of powers that Wraith has worked on for a very long time. Every power is rooted in some sort of scientific understanding; of course none of it is 'real' since superpowers don't exist, but there's a lot of attention paid to how various powers work, and why they are able to pass as realistic within Vigilance's own rules of science and magic.

I feel like your approach to technomancy could use some work in this respect. It leaves a lot of questions unanswered to me: How do any of the machines he makes function? Where does the matter come from with which he is able to create components for his machines (via his mercury-like substance)? How does circuitry work? How does his brain (an organic construct), naturally know how to combine man-made components to create machines, without any technological or mechanical knowledge of his own?

I hope this doesn't feel like I'm ripping on you; and I do apologise if I'm speaking out of turn. I just feel like it would be a shame for this character (whom I otherwise really like) to be lumbered with what I feel is an inadequate powerset in comparison to the rest of the sheet - and, indeed, to the other powersets of the approved characters thus far.

Perhaps consider scaling his powers back considerably. I feel he should not be able to simply create machines from any old components. Combining a clock and a toaster is not likely to make a firearm, for example. I feel his powers should solely be rooted in the ability to repurpose and rearrange parts; and, indeed, combine various parts from different machines to create something better, or entirely new. I think the main issue for me, in my mind, is that he needs to have access to the components he requires in order to use them; creating them from nothing seems far-fetched in my opinion.

This doesn't render him useless; he can carry a wealth of parts with him that he knows might come in useful, and if he requires anything else he can pick it up during the stops in various cities. I also think his powers should involve some kind of extensive understanding of mechanical concepts; rather than simply 'knowing everything' about machines, he should be able to look at the components he has available and very swiftly be able to mentally piece together how he might turn them into something else.

I hope this helps, because I'd really like to see this character accepted. Of course, Wraith might disagree with me entirely, in which case I'm more than certain he'll take the opportunity to publicly shame me and send me back to my corner. But this was just how things were looking from my angle; I like to think if someone else had opinions like this about any of my own characters, they would make them known to me.
1x Thank Thank
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Heathen
Raw
Avatar of Heathen

Heathen Astrologist Know-It-All

Member Seen 4 mos ago

@Tyler Babe are you and JK Rowling related like good lordt.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Lord Wraith
Raw
GM
Avatar of Lord Wraith

Lord Wraith Actually Three Otters in a Trenchcoat

Member Seen 41 min ago

@Tyler Babe are you and JK Rowling related like good lordt.


More like George R. R. Martin.
1x Laugh Laugh
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Atrophy
Raw
Avatar of Atrophy

Atrophy Meddlesome Kid

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

@Lord WraithHere we go.



Lemme know what I broke.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Bigg Slamm
Raw
Avatar of Bigg Slamm

Bigg Slamm The Biggest Fish in the Sea

Member Seen 2 yrs ago

@Tyler i don't know what was mistranstlated but you discribed exactly how i intend to use his powers. by no means did i intend to make something out of nothing. if you read his history he once turned a frige into an airconditioner. with the right reconfiguration of parts could easily happen.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Tyler
Raw
Avatar of Tyler

Tyler Me. I Am Tyler... / The Elusive Auteur

Member Seen 4 yrs ago

@Tyler i don't know what was mistranstlated but you discribed exactly how i intend to use his powers. by no means did i intend to make something out of nothing. if you read his history he once turned a frige into an airconditioner. with the right reconfiguration of parts could easily happen.


Well, then I guess you have it covered. Though I feel the need to clarify that I would not have offered an opinion on a sheet I hadn't thoroughly read in full. Alas, it was but an observation: do with it what you will.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Bigg Slamm
Raw
Avatar of Bigg Slamm

Bigg Slamm The Biggest Fish in the Sea

Member Seen 2 yrs ago

it was a well thought out observation and i thank you for it. :3
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Nemaisare
Raw
Avatar of Nemaisare

Nemaisare

Member Seen 12 hrs ago

So, who all is thinking their characters are starting with the convoy?

I think I've read a few histories that don't have the characters with them, but not sure.

Lucas is probably going to be part of the convoy, though how recently he's joined, I couldn't say. Yet. Must continue thinking about it. Also, yay for more information!
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by GreenGrenade
Raw
Avatar of GreenGrenade

GreenGrenade

Member Seen 1 day ago

So, who all is thinking their characters are starting with the convoy?

I think I've read a few histories that don't have the characters with them, but not sure.

Lucas is probably going to be part of the convoy, though how recently he's joined, I couldn't say. Yet. Must continue thinking about it. Also, yay for more information!

Gareth's probably been with them for a few days, a week at most (assuming they've been in Pointe Bordeaux for that long). I have no idea.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Tyler
Raw
Avatar of Tyler

Tyler Me. I Am Tyler... / The Elusive Auteur

Member Seen 4 yrs ago

So, who all is thinking their characters are starting with the convoy?

I think I've read a few histories that don't have the characters with them, but not sure.

Lucas is probably going to be part of the convoy, though how recently he's joined, I couldn't say. Yet. Must continue thinking about it. Also, yay for more information!


Emory's new to the convoy, for certain. However, I've been discussing that he has some historic connections to other members of the convoy, and I'm more than willing to establish similar relationships with others. He spent a good two years city-hopping before settling in Texas, so he's been all over the place and it's not entirely unlikely that he'd have met some people, even in passing. He also attended the PRCU for just over a year, beginning 2010.

<Snipped quote by Nemaisare>
Gareth's probably been with them for a few days, a week at most (assuming they've been in Pointe Bordeaux for that long). I have no idea.


To the best of my knowledge, the convoy will be arriving in Pointe Bordeaux at the start of the RP.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by GreenGrenade
Raw
Avatar of GreenGrenade

GreenGrenade

Member Seen 1 day ago

<Snipped quote by GreenGrenade>

To the best of my knowledge, the convoy will be arriving in Pointe Bordeaux at the start of the RP.

Ah, okay. I guess Gar's new to the convoy, then, lol.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Lord Wraith
Raw
GM
Avatar of Lord Wraith

Lord Wraith Actually Three Otters in a Trenchcoat

Member Seen 41 min ago

Yeah RP starts with the Convoy arriving at Pointe Bordeaux. Zeke will be joining it there as well.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Nemaisare
Raw
Avatar of Nemaisare

Nemaisare

Member Seen 12 hrs ago

Hmmm, Lucas went to the PRCU from 1995-1999, which is probably not useful for anyone else. But since that time, he has been part of a few efforts H.E.L.P. has made towards research, development, and the occasional protection/enforcement. So, anyone who's kept up ties with H.E.L.P. might have a small history of acquaintanceship with him, provided they've been to Canada.... And anyone else they'd have had to have crossed paths within the last year.

It's possible, though probably rather far-fetched, that he might have come across memories of some individuals while traveling, Zeke being one of them, as the first direction Lucas went was cross Canada then down. If he did encounter Emory either physically or through a memory, he'd probably remember it and make much of any re-encounter. Simply because His Sliminess is an extremely strange phenomenon as far as he's concerned.

Gareth, he has probably never met at all, despite proximity.

Not sure about Marcus or Ilani.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Lord Wraith
Raw
GM
Avatar of Lord Wraith

Lord Wraith Actually Three Otters in a Trenchcoat

Member Seen 41 min ago

| NAME(S): |
Benedict Fletcher


I'm afraid I have to reject this CS in its current state. Whilst I do feel the character has potential, I feel like it also could have benefitted from closer inspection of the OP in order to better inform the tone of the character and allow him to fit in more with the RP more seamlessly. In my opinion, his vigilante identity feels a little gimmicky in the context of this roleplay, which I intend to have a different tone than traditional 'crimefighting' narratives. Furthermore, it seems some of the RP rules have been overlooked and would advise you to read through them more thoroughly if you wish to adapt the CS and resubmit it. On a more practical note regarding other characters that have previously been accepted, your character's powerset is rendered somewhat obsolete by two existing characters, so you may also wish to rethink this choice at your own discretion. I hope to see an adaption of this sheet which better complements the story world as I do feel that both your characterisation and writing style have a lot of potential.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Tyler
Raw
Avatar of Tyler

Tyler Me. I Am Tyler... / The Elusive Auteur

Member Seen 4 yrs ago

Hmmm, Lucas went to the PRCU from 1995-1999, which is probably not useful for anyone else. But since that time, he has been part of a few efforts H.E.L.P. has made towards research, development, and the occasional protection/enforcement. So, anyone who's kept up ties with H.E.L.P. might have a small history of acquaintanceship with him, provided they've been to Canada.... And anyone else they'd have had to have crossed paths within the last year.

It's possible, though probably rather far-fetched, that he might have come across memories of some individuals while traveling, Zeke being one of them, as the first direction Lucas went was cross Canada then down. If he did encounter Emory either physically or through a memory, he'd probably remember it and make much of any re-encounter. Simply because His Sliminess is an extremely strange phenomenon as far as he's concerned.

Gareth, he has probably never met at all, despite proximity.

Not sure about Marcus or Ilani.


I'm not sure how Emory will work along psychic types; I hadn't really considered it until it was brought up, but he doesn't really have a brain. (He's much like his creator, in that respect...) But whilst he lacks a brain in the traditional sense, he is still very much a sentient being that thinks, feels and the whatnot; it depends on how Minerva types work - do they interact with the brain, or with thoughts themselves? If the former, Emory may well be immune to psychic-based attacks.

Speaking particularly about Lucas, however, that raises further interesting questions, since his psychometry is touch-related. Emory's slime form is considered organic by my own terms, but it's also not a 'known' substance, it's unique to him. This makes me wonder whether he'd be immune to Lucas' prying touch, or whether the opposite would be true: would touching Emory act in the same way as touching an object, but with far more efficiency? Since he would essentially be coming into contact with a substance that had its own mind and thoughts, rather just ingrained memories.

I don't have a particular preference and I don't think it ultimately matters; the relationship between our characters promises to be an interesting dynamic that I'm really looking forward to. I'm just sort of tossing ideas around and raising questions, because I'm an antagonistic provocateur at the best of times and an [insert unsavoury words here] in the rest.

Perhaps @Lord Wraith has an opinion on how Em and Lucas/psychics in general would work.
↑ Top
1 Guest viewing this page
© 2007-2024
BBCode Cheatsheet