6 Guests viewing this page
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Fabulous Knight
Raw
Avatar of Fabulous Knight

Fabulous Knight Defender of the Tragically Un-fabulous

Member Seen 9 yrs ago

@Legion02I don't understand why we need to look at it from a more practical standpoint. I mean, this isn't our universe. It's our universe, if you get me. We literally have a god of physics, and while the universe might generally follow the laws we put into place -- not only do those laws include stuff like magic, but the laws also don't apply to us.

Plus, plants don't need to -- and don't -- depend on seasons.
Hidden 9 yrs ago 9 yrs ago Post by Muttonhawk
Raw
coGM
Avatar of Muttonhawk

Muttonhawk Let Slip the Corgis of War

Member Seen 3 days ago

There's two reasons why I don't mind the the sciency stuff.

1. It's fun to connect it to the fantastic.

2. It sets guidelines.

The science doesn't have to be hard and fast because, yes, we can break the rules as gods. However, when fantasy connects to a relatable reality, sometimes it helps to bridge the gaps in terms of interpretation. Some people are leaning more heavily on science than others, but they are much closer to guidelines than rules. Don't feel discouraged by it, just do your own thing. If there's a clash, there will be GM discretion as the be-all-end-all arbitration.

ADDENDUM: When you have multiple authors and arbitrary mythological and unexplained parts of the universe that have no connection to how we understand our universe at all, it tends to make people feel copped out if something they could not have known to consider comes up. It's all well and good for the authors of ancient mythology, because they didn't have to play play-by-post RPs with each other. The guidelines keep it to an understandable scope for us, and if one of us wants to add something fantastical, everyone can get a clear sense of its impact.
Hidden 9 yrs ago 9 yrs ago Post by Antarctic Termite
Raw
Avatar of Antarctic Termite

Antarctic Termite Resident of Mortasheen

Member Seen 6 mos ago

So...why do we need to deal with this "science" business? Persephone's kidnapping kickstarted the whole season thing, and the sun was Apollo's chariot. Less mythologically, we have the power to bend gravity, the skies, magic and chaos to our will. Why'd we need to make everything how it is in real life? This is just a fantasy, right?


It is a fantasy and once we have the basic resources down it'll pretty quickly start to resemble one, from my experience with Divinus, and honestly I really really hope it does. I think we just want to have things like tides, seasons, and oceans that are made of water instead of ammonia because we're used to the way those things work and want to roleplay in a world that starts off at least somewhat familiar to us.

I think we're putting those things in place so that they continue their functions via physics (universal blueprint magic) instead of conventional divine magic because it requires less regulation and in the end probably less work, too. Having moons like Earth does kills both the problem of extreme axial tilt and gives us our familiar tides, without having to do those things individually by magic. Creating life as we know it supplants the need to oxygenate the place manually. Volcanoes do warm up the planet's atmosphere and gives it cool shit like lava lakes, geothermal vents, and a whole host of other useful stuff. It's hard to be as creatively retroactively efficient in putting together an Earth-like planet as physics is, because it's physics that put together Earth originally, if you get my drift.

But the real reason is honestly because science is fun every now and again and you bet that Jvan's going to fill the ocean by vomiting water out of nowhere rather than exploiting comets because that's the line where magic is more entertaining and in-character.
2x Like Like
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Fabulous Knight
Raw
Avatar of Fabulous Knight

Fabulous Knight Defender of the Tragically Un-fabulous

Member Seen 9 yrs ago

@MuttonhawkI don't have anything against people using science, I was just confused as to why we were. --That said, I think we're bright/agreeable enough to roleplay without real-world guidelines; we seem good at hashing things out OOC. Oh, and I didn't mean arbitrary or unexplained when I said mythological.

@Antarctic TermiteI meant how we got the seasons and oceans &c. more than whether we had them. The difference between "water is the tears of a god weeping because there is no life" vs. "we got some H and some O".

Makes sense if people find it fun. I've never been a fan of it -- does anyone mind if I go more fantastical?
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Muttonhawk
Raw
coGM
Avatar of Muttonhawk

Muttonhawk Let Slip the Corgis of War

Member Seen 3 days ago

...I've never been a fan of it -- does anyone mind if I go more fantastical?


As long as we understand what's generally happening, I'd say go for it.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Fabulous Knight
Raw
Avatar of Fabulous Knight

Fabulous Knight Defender of the Tragically Un-fabulous

Member Seen 9 yrs ago

@MuttonhawkStuff like the above examples -- cause will lead to effect like anything else, it'll just be magical/fantastical in nature.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Antarctic Termite
Raw
Avatar of Antarctic Termite

Antarctic Termite Resident of Mortasheen

Member Seen 6 mos ago

Makes sense if people find it fun. I've never been a fan of it -- does anyone mind if I go more fantastical?


Please do. I'm with you on the creation process.

For the record I still intend to post at some or other point but I'm also still procrastinating. By studying. Which is an oddly useful form of procrastination.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by ArekTheAbsolute
Raw
Avatar of ArekTheAbsolute

ArekTheAbsolute

Member Seen 9 yrs ago

Speaking of creations here is the creation post for the Orbs of Darkness Julkolfyr made. They are bad things, very bad things.


Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Kho
Raw
GM
Avatar of Kho

Kho

Member Seen 7 mos ago

@MuttonhawkStuff like the above examples -- cause will lead to effect like anything else, it'll just be magical/fantastical in nature.


Just remember, even if you create stuff magically, the way they are going to be perceived in the mortal realm is going to be very different and over a different timeframe.
If, for instance, Jvan DOES vommit water, it might be perceived as a hail of water from space, or strange atmospheric conditions leading to a ten thousand year period of constant rain or whatever.
The gods themselves may not stick by the laws set out in the blueprint, but when manifesting into reality, their actions will find a way to happen while obeying the laws set out. So, if you create a completely new species out of nothing, the laws would make it so that it evolved from something else etc.

As magic is part of the blueprint, obviously it means that fantastical things can happen too.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Fabulous Knight
Raw
Avatar of Fabulous Knight

Fabulous Knight Defender of the Tragically Un-fabulous

Member Seen 9 yrs ago

@KhoWait what? I did not know that. That is very interesting.

So you say that fantastical elements i.e. magic is written into the fabric of reality...does this mean that willing a being into existence, as part of magic (e.g. using the Adversary's demon portfolio) would be manifested as the magical birth it is, or would it too have "evolved"? --And how does said retroactive evolution interlock with Slough's domain?
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Kho
Raw
GM
Avatar of Kho

Kho

Member Seen 7 mos ago

@KhoWait what? I did not know that. That is very interesting.

So you say that fantastical elements i.e. magic is written into the fabric of reality...does this mean that willing a being into existence, as part of magic (e.g. using the Adversary's demon portfolio) would be manifested as the magical birth it is, or would it too have "evolved"? --And how does said retroactive evolution interlock with Slough's domain?


As much as possible, the laws will resist creatio ex nihilo. So demons, being unique beings, may manifest as creations who have emerged from the 'gaps' created by Jvan in pre-existence, Mammon may have created his own separate plain where demons have evolved and then can emerge into the larger universe. Or, if there is nothing for it, creatio ex nihiilo - a drop of something from Mammon, which then develops into a small demon, which then develops on etc.
It may take a few seconds for Mammon, but eons in mortal Time, or if the creation in question is unique, it may take a shorter or longer period - if you don't specify the length in mortals years in your post, one of the GMs will specify.

This is mainly to avoid the absurd situation we had in the previous RP where humans had been created ten days prior, but we had humans who were 90 years old -.-
1x Like Like
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Double Capybara
Raw
Avatar of Double Capybara

Double Capybara Thank you for releasing me

Member Seen 3 mos ago

Is it such a trouble? In most mythologies earth is only a few thousand years old.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Kho
Raw
GM
Avatar of Kho

Kho

Member Seen 7 mos ago

Is it such a trouble? In most mythologies earth is only a few thousand years old.


Yup, that is in mythologies.
Mortals can believe what they want, but the reality must make sense xD
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Kho
Raw
GM
Avatar of Kho

Kho

Member Seen 7 mos ago

Is it such a trouble? In most mythologies earth is only a few thousand years old.


For instance, in the last RP, Cyclone played a deluded character who believed that there was only one god and ascribed all the miracles that were happening to him. The reality was that there were many gods and they were the ones doing the miracles.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Dawnscroll
Raw
Avatar of Dawnscroll

Dawnscroll Ordo ad Logos

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

Here's a question: Might vs Time. I'll use Logos as an example: We can use might to raise mountains, continents, and so forth. And we can probably do so quite suddenly for super dramatic effect.

Logos controls gravity (among others), and you can substitute any god with their power for a similar scenario. What's to prevent him from grabbing alot of the base material from space, using his power to mold them into a hole, set it into an orbit, and then just lob a few more meteors into it to make the terrain. Heck, like Jan said a few icy meteors could result in oceans. But what if this is done over millions/billions of years rather than "shazam"?
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Legion02
Raw

Legion02

Member Seen 6 days ago

<Snipped quote by Double Capybara>

For instance, in the last RP, Cyclone played a deluded character who believed that there was only one god and ascribed all the miracles that were happening to him. The reality was that there were many gods and they were the ones doing the miracles.


Just out of curiousity, how did the others god react to this and how did Cyclone's god react when he got confronted by other gods?
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Kho
Raw
GM
Avatar of Kho

Kho

Member Seen 7 mos ago

Here's a question: Might vs Time. I'll use Logos as an example: We can use might to raise mountains, continents, and so forth. And we can probably do so quite suddenly for super dramatic effect.

Logos controls gravity (among others), and you can substitute any god with their power for a similar scenario. What's to prevent him from grabbing alot of the base material from space, using his power to mold them into a hole, set it into an orbit, and then just lob a few more meteors into it to make the terrain. Heck, like Jan said a few icy meteors could result in oceans. But what if this is done over millions/billions of years rather than "shazam"?



I'm lost. What are you asking xDDDD
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Kho
Raw
GM
Avatar of Kho

Kho

Member Seen 7 mos ago

<Snipped quote by Kho>

Just out of curiousity, how did the others god react to this and how did Cyclone's god react when he got confronted by other gods?


Cyclone was actually playing a Hero who eventually became a demigod.
He never came to face with many gods - maybe only two. The first he met was Vestec, and he assumed that this was the one god who existed. The second he met was a god who cursed him, he just got really annoyed at him and assumed these were lesser gods, nothing in comparison with the ultimate god.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Legion02
Raw

Legion02

Member Seen 6 days ago

<Snipped quote by Dawnscroll>


I'm lost. What are you asking xDDDD


I think Dawnscroll is try to ask that, as his god's power concerns gravity (and time), couldn't he just use that to create new celestial objects instead of using might to do so.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Dawnscroll
Raw
Avatar of Dawnscroll

Dawnscroll Ordo ad Logos

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

@Legion02 Well, using my gods powers AND time. For instance, could Sloud just simply create bacteria and give that a few billion years to evolve into a higher life form. Since we're divine immortals, Time means nothing. So could someone achieve their goals, slower, if they had the means and creativity to do so.
↑ Top
6 Guests viewing this page
© 2007-2024
BBCode Cheatsheet