@vancexentan

So what is the final consensus. Are we doing the first choice or the second one?

There is no real consensus.

It's seems to be

1-2 - Wing/Animal

2-2 Me/Trinity

3-2 Animal/Unlucky.

I'd personally prefer 2 or 3 but that would alienate you a bit Nightwing since you prefer hero characters in the case of 3. Personally the is a reason I would be interested in villains. It's not often done and it'd be very fun to play the super villains as the protagonists with the heroes being our pseudo antagonists. But the end game would be very weird it'd have to be whatever we can cobble together. Hell we may even end up in jail. It also brings along the question of how would we start off? One big event that blows up out of proportion that leads to us teaming up? The big bad recruiting us all for the big scheme? Do we just team up for practical purposes? That would need to be solved before we head into a villains scenario. Heroes would be simple enough. Be in the city, do hero stuff. Academy would probably just start off with us on our first day of school or the day before school when some event happens and we meet each other before the stuff goes on at school.

Well, the numbers show that the second choice is the most popular....

But still, we have to remember that this is taking place in My Hero Academia universe. If we are Pro Heroes then we could know each other from the days in the Academy.

Not necessarily. People could have come here from different cities. Chances are there won't be too many but there is still that option.

I don't mind if we do 2 or 3, it does not matter to me which option gets chosen. Playing the villains would be rather interesting now that I think about it. It would make sense for one big baddie to call us all together against the #1 hero xD I think that would be easy to manage. Some of our characters who share a common goal can occasionally team up as well. That is if we are going for the villain route. We probably have to change the name to 'My Villain Academia' xD

Ok then how about this. It starts off as us being good but the city itself sees us more as a burden thanks to the destruction we cause when fighting baddies. So instead of us being heros, we're seen as villians and so someone or a group amongst the rest of the population step up to stop us. After a while we're just like "fuck it" you want to see us as baddies well then here ya go!"

Later on something much bigger and more powerful than us comes along and we have to stop it despite the rep we have been given in order to bring about honor to our team.

I suppose we can do that if the plot goes that way. What do you guys think? Should we be heroes from the start to finish, be heroes who are forced into villainy by one reason or another, or start as villains?

Is it too late to join? Cause I am definitely interested in being apart of this role play

No it is not too late there's certainly room for another player. Welcome aboard.

Thank you very much XD. I know I literally just joined but I've been reading whats been going on so far and the second idea you had was probably my favorite of the original three suggestions. As for the new idea I honestly like all three but the whole heroes turning into villains interests me the most if I had to pick only one.

Alright well just as a forewarning these are typically the sheets I expect from a roleplayer. I tend to go a bit longer myself but ignoring my quentin richards on the sheet page this should give you a fair example of what I want.

http://www.roleplayerguild.com/topics/125599-mobile-suit-gundam-londo-bells-rising/char#post-3624578

Seems fair enough, Im sure I can make a character or two that meet your expectations. I already have a few ideas in mind for the characters I wanna make but that can wait for when the role play is actually made.

Alright just wanted to give that out before hand. I'll wait one more day before just going with idea 2 and then seeing how the roleplay progresses.

Alright then, Im sure the others will wanna say something later when they come on so for now I shall wait. Still looking forward to this so best hopes to the future.

@vancexentan

Funny enough I agree say for the personality. Sorry but I am one of those people who let the character gain one of his own. It's stupid but for me it's easier. It's either that or I just bulletin some traits but usually it's the former

Personality is used to have a hard lock on the characters likes, dislikes, and general ways the gm can use the character's feelings to manipulate how he or she would feel in an event or for specific character arc. You may disagree with it but I stand firm where I am. I am willing to let things slim down for personality if it is descriptive enough but that's something any person who's played Dungeons and Dragons knows is important. You can let a character develop over the story but they need a firm set of morals, ideals, and lines they're willing/not willing to cross.

I'm good either way but still lean to my preference. In the end as long as the story is enjoyable that's really what matters

And the roleplayer's consistency in the RP (posting when asked, maintaining a certain level of attendance, etc)

I can only attain to the fact that I will post as often as I can I can't speak for the others.

I like the idea of having heroes turn into villains. No objection here :p