Hidden 8 yrs ago Post by Kreutzer
Raw
coGM
Avatar of Kreutzer

Kreutzer

Member Seen 3 yrs ago

@olcharlieboi want it in a separate post so the char tab shows a clear number of characters or want me to edit my original char post?
Hidden 8 yrs ago Post by olcharlieboi
Raw
GM
Avatar of olcharlieboi

olcharlieboi Master Mind of the Swarm

Member Seen 1 mo ago

@Kreutzer
Doesn't matter there, having it in the same would still let me keep track of how many characters, though would also allow me to keep track the players easier.
1x Like Like
Hidden 8 yrs ago Post by Yui
Raw
Avatar of Yui

Yui licked a raincoat once / (don't do that)

Member Seen 3 yrs ago

So due to some things coming up irl, I've got to cut an RP from my schedule since I'm losing some time in my days. And I figured the smart decision is to cut the one that hasn't started yet. Which...is this one ._.

Unfortunately I'll have to scoop. Best of luck though (^_^)/
1x Like Like
Hidden 8 yrs ago Post by Lucius Cypher
Raw
Avatar of Lucius Cypher

Lucius Cypher Looking For Group

Member Seen 26 days ago

Hopefully new and improved CS.

Hidden 8 yrs ago Post by olcharlieboi
Raw
GM
Avatar of olcharlieboi

olcharlieboi Master Mind of the Swarm

Member Seen 1 mo ago

@JustYui
Does suck having to hear that, I wont try to change your mind if that's what you decided there, best of luck to you as well.
Hidden 8 yrs ago Post by pkken
Raw
Avatar of pkken

pkken

Member Seen 1 mo ago

Gotta brainstorm a little
1x Like Like
Hidden 8 yrs ago 8 yrs ago Post by Heckno12
Raw
Avatar of Heckno12

Heckno12 That Guy

Member Seen 2 mos ago

@Turboshitter

Y'know I thought your name was Turboshifter originally. Glad to be wrong.

Edit: Also, I have to say a fight between our characters would be a pain for both sides. Dan would be almost impossible to hit and completely unable to damage Makoto.
1x Laugh Laugh
Hidden 8 yrs ago Post by Turboshitter
Raw
Avatar of Turboshitter

Turboshitter Ubiquitous. Mendacious. Polyglottal.

Member Seen 7 mos ago

@kidjab
It's alright, there would be ways to get past the lack of kinetic energy like having a device apart of her suit that constantly generates kinetic energy since she can take it some from her surroundings if I remember what I read. as for when we are starting, that is uncertain atm. It could be a little while since we did have a lot of people applying for the roleplay and I want to give everyone a chance to actually apply with character(s). Because if they don't get in before the start they would have to wait for the second school year, and at that point we would have split classes.


Really, really late, but I felt I had to comment on this (and believe me, I say this with no ill will intended). I know this is a superhero RP so "lolphysics what's that?", but this makes my inner science guy laugh so hard knowing that a suit device like that would have to be some sort of magic "infinite vacuum energy" generator in order to supply enough kinetic energy even to create something as small as a marble lol. Momo's powers have the same problem, really. Bitches be dissing MC Albert and his homeboys special relativity and conservation of energy xD

1x Laugh Laugh
Hidden 8 yrs ago 8 yrs ago Post by Turboshitter
Raw
Avatar of Turboshitter

Turboshitter Ubiquitous. Mendacious. Polyglottal.

Member Seen 7 mos ago

@Turboshitter

Y'know I thought your name was Turboshifter originally. Glad to be wrong.

Edit: Also, I have to say a fight between our characters would be a pain for both sides. Dan would be almost impossible to hit and completely unable to damage Makoto.


Yeah, I imagine it'd be somewhat akin to an obese, geriatric elephant trying to swat a coked-up housefly with its trunk after undergoing general anesthetic xD

Fair warning though, she punches pretty damn fast. Doesn't take super reflexes to throw a super-speed punch (if my stupidly basic napkin math is indicative of anything, the amount of kinetic energy she can produce with a punch would move an arm with the same mass as hers at around 200 m/s).

EDIT: Nope my math was way off. Turns out Makoto's arms should weigh about 22-28kg each given her overall mass, so her punches would only move at 55 m/s or 123mph.
1x Like Like
Hidden 8 yrs ago 8 yrs ago Post by Counter Coup
Raw
Avatar of Counter Coup

Counter Coup

Member Seen 7 yrs ago

Only thing missing is the Hero Outfit, which I have no idea on!


Hidden 8 yrs ago Post by Kreutzer
Raw
coGM
Avatar of Kreutzer

Kreutzer

Member Seen 3 yrs ago

@Turboshitter hey i tried to have a tad more tact than that ;) but yeah, the pseudoscience hurts me inside too
Hidden 8 yrs ago Post by kidjab
Raw
Avatar of kidjab

kidjab Brawling Aegis

Member Seen 7 yrs ago

.... ok point was?

Green lantern power battery easily believed?
Speed force easily believed?

But the idea of a creating a vacuum to reduce or crest no such thing as air resistance. Or to have a super conductor so that it has no physical interaction with the body of the metal so again reducing friction. Isnt plausible even if I may not be the best at describing the idea. The entire process or idea of an infinite mover isn't plausible and falls apart?

But all other things based outside of reality are?

Rather confusing.
Hidden 8 yrs ago 8 yrs ago Post by Kreutzer
Raw
coGM
Avatar of Kreutzer

Kreutzer

Member Seen 3 yrs ago

@kidjab your wording is very hard to understand when you're talking about this kind of stuff so forgive me if i'm misunderstanding anything,

@NightmareInd @olcharlieboi tagging you in case you disagree

the DC universe is in no way linked with BNHA. using Green Lantern Power Batteries as an example is kinda just wrong in itself, as quirks/powers are indeed supernatural occurrences but falls strictly in the path of genetics, so it seems. Supernatural objects and such should not be assumed plausible for this reason, as the unworldly aspect of this universe largely falls into the people living in it, give or take some advances in real world technology.

The problems are spanning in how you're trying to establish your quirk. Things such as you say the aerodynamics of my female character almost like a vacuum etc are part of her quirk, whereas what you're trying to explain is a machine that supposedly feeds your character's.

Because you want your quirk, seemingly, to be powered by surrounding forces you also want a normal power supply but for this you need a machine that just can't exist, this is a flaw with the quirk itself.

As an example, without this machine if you're fighting a giant robot with this quirk, it runs towards you and you draw from it's kinetic energy to create some kind of, i don't know, wall. For whatever reason. In doing this, you're taking that energy from the robot, and the robot will slow down/stop moving. Because you can't draw from something's mass, and Kinetic Energy depends on mass and velocity, you're gaining almost if not all of your quirk's power by draining velocity. Because of this, your idea of the infinite energy machine can't work because as soon as you draw power from it, the ball bearing or whatever is inside will stop, and the machine becomes useless.

My recommendation is to keep the energy structures, etc. However I personally would scrap the idea of a constant machine and just have it as a downside of the quirk that you need to draw the energy from somewhere.

However, if you would like a machine to draw things from as part of your hero suit, then I recommend a battery powered motor that can fit to your back like a propeller. That way you can almost use it as a jet propulsion for roller blades, and draw power from it for your quirk without having the machine stop, it would just use more of the battery's electricity (which as a downside would probably be best to have a finite supply).

I hope that was helpful

Edit: Simply put, the quirk can break physics ofc thats the point of them, the battle suit however has to be built by someone. So that kind of can't, and I haven't seen any incantations of one in BNHA so far where the suit breaks physics.
Hidden 8 yrs ago 8 yrs ago Post by NightmareInd
Raw
coGM
Avatar of NightmareInd

NightmareInd Edgelord McEdgyness

Member Seen 3 mos ago

@JustYui

Too bad to see you go. Good luck with other RPs and IRL.

@Lucius Cypher

The suit looks good to me now, and assuming you didn't change anything to the rest of the CS (except the other section, I've seen those changes.) you are accepted! Although I would recommend having the duration of the battery less so you can upgrade it in the RP and have some more development, but it is not required.

@Turboshitter@kidjab

Guys, this is a superhero RP. Let's not make this a Physics battle for an RP where almost all the powers are not able to get explained by current Physics.

Seriously though, here is a list of all the Quirks seen in the Anime ALONE that can not be explained by current Physics:

As long as the Quirk itself sounds reasonable and the Physics indirectly around the Quirk sound good, no reason to bomb IRL stuff on it. I know this sounds hypocrite from a guy who bombed physics on an exo-suit, but an exo-suit is not a Quirk.

On that note: The Hero suits are no Quirks either. They may do small inexplainable things, like cool people down through fibers, but it still is a bit logical. The idea of having some kind of vacuum thingy which has infinite kinetic energy is not logical. @Kreutzer's generator idea is though. You can use that or my earlier idea to capture the lost kinetic energy and reuse it, but infinite kinetic energy is a no.

@Counter Coup

So far she looks good, although I would like for you to have her not have as powerful breath. If one sneeze at low age can freeze half a classroom, imagine what a focused exhalation could do? If you can nerf that a bit, you seem good to go for me.
1x Like Like
Hidden 8 yrs ago Post by Lucius Cypher
Raw
Avatar of Lucius Cypher

Lucius Cypher Looking For Group

Member Seen 26 days ago

@Lucius Cypher

The suit looks good to me now, and assuming you didn't change anything to the rest of the CS (except the other section, I've seen those changes.) you are accepted! Although I would recommend having the duration of the battery less so you can upgrade it in the RP and have some more development, but it is not required.


I politely disagree with the battery duration. I know one hour might seem like a lot for a fight, but one hour isn't going to be enough if Asahi has to wear his suit for say, a whole class. Which I imagine will take at least fifty minutes. Or if he goes out on a patrol of some sort, which certainly lasts longer than an hour. And right now he only has one battery which takes a few hours to recharge.

I understand that the Guardian One is quite powerful on its own, but it's only useful for about an hour per day. Two if Asahi can charge his batteries between bouts. Granted this weakness may be overcome if Asahi can get his hands on funding to create more batteries. Whether he can or not relies mostly on what happens to him IC.
Hidden 8 yrs ago Post by NightmareInd
Raw
coGM
Avatar of NightmareInd

NightmareInd Edgelord McEdgyness

Member Seen 3 mos ago

@Lucius Cypher

Well, considering not every class needs it but a battle rarely exceeds 30 minutes, probably should have the battery drain more in combat.
Hidden 8 yrs ago 8 yrs ago Post by Lucius Cypher
Raw
Avatar of Lucius Cypher

Lucius Cypher Looking For Group

Member Seen 26 days ago

A battle perhaps. Less so if say, Asahi has to get there. Combat and running long distances are both just as intensive in the suit, granted one is less lethal then the other.

While I know their powers can't compare, I gave Asahi's armor a hard one hour limit for much the same reason All Might has roughly three hours (or less) on his: it's so that it can't be inside of it all the time. The power is going to be used regardless if Asahi is active or idle in his suit, so he can't just waste time standing around doing nothing for most of it.

And if I go with your suggestion that the power drains if he's more active, then hobble his time to thirty minutes, against a foe that Asahi can't overpower immediately (which is a lot more then you'd think since the Guardian One isn't made for big damage), he'll last maybe ten minutes against a foe he can't defeat. And that's assuming he didn't already use up most of his power just getting to the fight, like if he is on patrol through the city during a class lesson or something.

Kinda hard to be the party tank when you're only useful for about ten minutes.its about as bad as Deku's One for All except Asahi doesn't break his limbs everything he dons the suit. and the Guardian One isn't nearly as powerful as Deku's One For All when it's in use either. The Guardian One is made for endurance, and ideally it does a good job at it.
Hidden 8 yrs ago Post by NightmareInd
Raw
coGM
Avatar of NightmareInd

NightmareInd Edgelord McEdgyness

Member Seen 3 mos ago

Seems fine then, you make some pretty good arguments so let's keep it as it is.
Hidden 8 yrs ago Post by Lucius Cypher
Raw
Avatar of Lucius Cypher

Lucius Cypher Looking For Group

Member Seen 26 days ago

Grazti. Is it okay to post him in the character tab?
Hidden 8 yrs ago 8 yrs ago Post by Kalas
Raw
Avatar of Kalas

Kalas "Time to party!"

Member Seen 3 mos ago

WIPWIPWIPWIPWIPWIPWIPWIPWIPWIPWIPWIPWIPWIPWIP


This weekend has been hectic but I should have my sheet done by tonight.
↑ Top
© 2007-2024
BBCode Cheatsheet