[OOC] D&D 5e -- The Lost Children

[rush99999]

@Guardian Angel Haruki

While that may be the case, there has never once been an instance in real life where someone has vanished simply because the extradimensional being that controlled said person's every action got bored of controlling that person. Had it not been for the people playing Boram, Bobbin, and Mirdas losing interest in the game, their characters would still be around and chances are their secrets would have eventually come to light.

And on top of that, answer me this. Since all 3 of these characters are now gone and therefore no longer have any impact on the story what so ever, what harm is there in revealing their secrets?

[Guardian Angel Haruki]

@rush99999

JBRam2002, Pennydumb123, and Cu Chulainn might want to use their characters in another RP in the future. To reveal the secrets behind them would not only harm any potential surprises for that future RP (should you be in the same RP as them), but it is also ultimately up to the players as to whether or not they would like to reveal their secrets or not. For you to demand them to just reveal their character's secrets, like you did to JBRam2002 is just flat out rude and inconsiderate in my opinion.

[rush99999]

@Guardian Angel Haruki

What makes you think I was demanding?

[Guardian Angel Haruki]

@JBRam2002

Since you're out of the game now, what was Bobbin's secret stuff that you PM'd to Haruki at the start of the game? The only way we'll know now is if you tell us.

@rush99999

I'll admit that I misremembered the tone of your post, but I did get the impression from the last sentence.

While it is true that it is the only way you'll find out, it's just not as satisfying to reveal it as things are now, and it's frustrating. I have seen RPers reuse their characters for other RPs, so it's not like you'll never get another chance to find out their secrets. Save the joy of the surprise for that time!

I apologize for my mistake on the tone of your post.

[rush99999]

<Snipped quote by rush99999>

I'll admit that I misremembered the tone of your post, but I did get the impression from the last sentence.

@Guardian Angel Haruki

I can kinda see why.

---

While it is true that it is the only way you'll find out, it's just not as satisfying to reveal it as things are now, and it's frustrating. I have seen RPers reuse their characters for other RPs, so it's not like you'll never get another chance to find out their secrets. Save the joy of the surprise for that time!

@Guardian Angel Haruki

There's a chance they won't though. I've had a few characters I only used once and never plan on using again. And in my opinion, an unsatisfying reveal is still better than no reveal.

---

I apologize for my mistake on the tone of your post.

@Guardian Angel Haruki

Apology accepted.

[Cu Chulainn]

@Guardian Angel Haruki

Would a Centaur be fine?

[Guardian Angel Haruki]

@Cu Chulainn Yes, a centaur is perfectly fine.

[The Harbinger of Ferocity]

The one time I do not play a beast race and some half of the party is. Oh well, at least Shaedra Galandoel is much outside my usual realm of character and characterization. A centaur at this point would be quite par for the course here.

[Cu Chulainn]

Apologies if we're waiting for me to continue. I've been indulging in my copy of Mordenkainen's Tome of Foes.

[rush99999]

@Cu Chulainn

Whodenkainen's Tome of Whatnow?

[Cu Chulainn]

@rush99999

I got it

[ihinka]

I'm not sure if we are stalling because of real life stuff or if the juice has simply left his RP. Either way, I give it a week and I'll be leaving.

Take care, people.

[The Harbinger of Ferocity]

I am going to need toss my lot in with @ihinka's approach. This has all stalled out entirely now at the moment, which is a sad, unfortunate place for it to be. Given as much, I will withdraw as well if nothing comes by week's end.

[rush99999]

I think the only people we're waiting on right now are @ihinka and @0 Azzy 0.

[ihinka]

@rush99999 If we were waiting on me I wouldn't have bothered to write my previous post -_-

[rush99999]

@ihinka

I'm pretty sure we were waiting on you back then as well. Whenever there's a DM post another one usually isn't posted until all the PCs have made a post.

[ihinka]

@rush99999 I have no intention of arguing with you. Nor do I need you to explain to me how posting order works. It's pretty obvious we are waiting on the missing in action players, not me, as I've been among the active posters.

@Guardian Angel Haruki Either way, regardless if this is dead or not, I'm out. I don't need the attitude.