@Scarifar, Astarte's going to approach Ferghus with a couple requests during the Timeskip, alright? One of them ought to be fairly costly and the other is more of a vanity thing xD
Dunno, considering they're not Gods of the Forge or even demigods of it, I assume strong enough to be somewhat better than average steel.
<Snipped quote by Frettzo>
That's grossly unfair. 5 Might Points is strong enough to be Damascus Steel.
<Snipped quote by ActRaiserTheReturned>
"this sort of steel could be made so sharp, durable and mighty that a full motion swing through castle walls would slash straight through"
Certainly not that strong, considering castle walls are thicker than the length of any sword.
<Snipped quote by Frettzo>
Damascus Steel is extremely high grade steel. That's at 5 Might Points. . . now maybe a few swings can't cut through Castle Walls, but they could dig through a wall single handedly, I bet you.
How strong can Primal Steel be at 20 Might?
<Snipped quote by ActRaiserTheReturned>
It was 20 Khookies, not Might xP
As for Damascus Steel, I assure you, it could not cut through castle walls. It was just an extraordinarily hard steel, extremely durable and could be honed to a sharpness no other steel could.
I'd say that this 'Primal' Steel, as it cost 20 Khookies, would be a buffed up version of Damascus steel, plus some magical properties. Very hard, with wards protecting against all but mid-high level spells, can be sharpened to a very fine edge and it is likely that badly made blades would be cut or shatter upon contact with it. Armour made from it would be understandably of high quality, the wards would help against magic. It would fare better against firearms than normal armour did, but nothing like, for instance, kevlar.
<Snipped quote by Kho>
Ah. . .um, I'm changing the name of this steel then. But, to be fair, for 1500's and 1800's fire arms, I don't know if Kevlar is needed?
<Snipped quote by ActRaiserTheReturned>
Well, we won't be having 1500's grade firearms for a long time yet. Don't worry though, we'll eventually have our fantastical, impossibly hard metals (as any self-respecting fantasy world must). Any that are created at this point in time, however, must be exceedingly rare. Like, rarer than oxygen on the moon.
<Snipped quote by Kho>
So non-existent?
<Snipped quote by Kho>
Ah. . .um, I'm changing the name of this steel then. But, to be fair, for 1500's and 1800's fire arms, I don't know if Kevlar is needed?
<Snipped quote by ActRaiserTheReturned>
I mean no matter how hard metal armor is, its weight is prohibitive
@Kho I see this from another perspective. What we are experiencing right now might be the Era of Magic. It's preferable as you say, to have technology slowly progress and eventually, overtake(?) magic as the dominant force. It will certainly be nice to see how this will play out in this RP.
<Snipped quote by ActRaiserTheReturned>
Those old-fashioned muskets were really powerful. Musket bullets would crush through your bones as opposed to just clip off them like modern bullets do. Not to mention that the old rifle rounds were also something like 0.70 caliber.
As in for Damascus steel, pretty sure that to our knowledge it was just steel with a slight vanadium impurity and a special forging process. Even today that alloy is used, and while it might be slightly superior it's really not that huge of an advantage.
So I think you're underestimating guns and overestimated metal armor. I mean no matter how hard metal armor is, its weight is prohibitive and blunt trauma will still kill you. Hell, slings were extremely effective against armored enemies and Ialu has Wi slingers than are probably more deadly than historical slingers.
Have no idea what you're getting on to Act, but the point Cyclone was trying to make is that in real life firearms out-matched even the best armours.