Chase and Danny were sitting together on one of the couches, deep in conversation about their own Halloween plans. “So, what’s the plan for Halloween?” Danny asked as he tossed a candy corn in his mouth “It’s our first holiday together as boyfriends, and I feel like we should do something...”
Chase leaned back, crossing his arms with a smirk. “Well, I was thinking we could hit up a haunted house or two. I heard about this one in Brooklyn that’s supposed to be super intense, like actual actors and animatronics.”
Danny shook his head vigorously. “No thanks. I deal with enough scary things as Spider-Man.” He shuddered. “Any other ideas?”
Chase pulled out his phone and showed Danny an ad for a big costume party happening at an old warehouse downtown. “It’s this huge Halloween rave. Costumes mandatory, lots of music, and no cover if you show up in a superhero costume. Figured we’d fit right in.”
Danny thought about it for a moment. “I guess…” To be honest, Danny wasn’t a big fan of big parties like this. He was always awkward at them. He figured it wouldn’t be so bad having Chase be there with him. “I mean, it’s way better than getting jump-scared every five seconds in a haunted house.
Chase noticed Danny’s hesitation and gave him a reassuring smile. “Hey, we don’t have to go if you’re not feeling it. We could always do something more low-key. But if we do go, we can stick together the whole time. No pressure to dance or anything crazy. We’ll just be the coolest couple in the room, you know?”
Danny smiled at that. “Thanks, Chase. I do want to go—I just get a little anxious at big parties. But I think it’ll be fun as long as we’re together.”
Chase nodded, giving Danny’s shoulder a squeeze. “You’ve got nothing to worry about. Plus, we get to show off our costumes. And hey, if it gets too much, we can always dip out early, grab some snacks, and have our own little movie night.”
Danny’s smile widened. “That actually sounds perfect. Let’s try the rave, and if it’s not our vibe, we’ll do our own thing. I like the idea of us just hanging out and enjoying Halloween our way.”
Chase leaned in, giving Danny a quick kiss. “Then it’s settled. We’ll make the most of it, whatever we end up doing. Besides, it’s our first Halloween together, so as long as we’re having fun, that’s all that matters.”
Danny nodded, feeling excited about their plans. “Yeah, you’re right. Let’s do it.”
“And hey, maybe we’ll get to show off a little—Spider-Man and Talkback, saving the dance floor.”
“Oh um… about that. Wouldn’t showing up as Spider-Man and Talkback be a little too… obvious?”
Chase tilted his head, considering Danny’s point. “Yeah, good call. We don’t want to blow our cover, especially not at a huge party like that. We could go in our regular costumes, but that might just be asking for trouble.” He smirked, an idea clearly forming in his mind. “How about this? Instead of going as ourselves, we switch it up. You go as a superhero version of me, and I’ll go as a superhero version of you. No one will ever expect it.”
Danny laughed. “You mean, like, you in the pink and purple Spider suit and me in your Talkback gear? That’s… actually kinda brilliant.”
Chase nodded eagerly, getting more excited. “Yeah! We could totally make it work. I’ll rock your colors, web-slingers, and all, and you can wear the Fistigons. We’ll still be in costume, but no one will think we’re actually Spider-Man and Talkback. It’s perfect.”
Danny grinned. “You’re gonna look fabulous in pink and purple.”
“And you’re gonna look badass with the Fistigons. Here’s to our first Halloween as boyfriends—and making it one for the books.”
—-
The warehouse was packed with partygoers, each one dressed in elaborate costumes that ranged from classic monsters to pop culture icons and, of course, plenty of superhero lookalikes. The walls were draped in cobwebs, and green and purple lights cast an eerie glow over the entire space. A DJ was set up in the corner, blasting a mix of electronic beats and Halloween remixes.
Decorations hung from the ceiling, including fake bats, dangling skeletons, and flickering jack-o’-lanterns. Fog machines added a layer of mist around the ground, and the occasional strobe light created an exciting atmosphere. A bar set up along one wall served themed drinks in glowing cups.
Chase and Danny made their way through the crowd, Chase dressed in Danny’s pink and purple Spider-Man suit, and Danny rocking Chase’s Talkback gear with the glowing Fistigons. “Dude, this awesome!” Chase exclaimed. “You look cool in my gear. It’s like those Fistigons were made for you!”
Danny flexed his hands. “Thanks! I’ve gotta say, this is a lot of fun. I can see why you love these things. They make me feel… powerful.” He giggled. “And look at you! You’re pulling off the Spider suit way better than I expected. Pink and purple really suits you.”
Chase struck a dramatic pose. “Maybe I’ll start a trend. Chase Stein, the fabulous Spider-Man. Can’t believe I haven’t worn spandex before—it’s actually kind of freeing!”
Danny blushed. Chase really filled out his suit well. Danny tried to keep his composure, but his eyes lingered a little longer than he should have. Chase really did look good in the pink and purple Spider suit, his athletic build accentuating every detail. The way the fabric hugged his body made Danny’s heart skip a beat, and he quickly looked away, trying to focus on the party around them.
Chase caught the blush on Danny’s cheeks and grinned. “What’s the matter, Spidey? See something you like?”
Danny laughed nervously, rubbing the back of his neck. “Maybe… just didn’t expect you to look this good in my suit. It’s… distracting.”
Chase chuckled, enjoying Danny’s flustered reaction. “Distracting, huh? Guess I’ll have to wear it more often, just for you.”
Danny shook his head, still smiling. “You’re ridiculous. But hey, whatever gets you in spandex more often, I won’t complain.”
Chase and Danny soon found themselves at the bar, picking up glowing drinks. They clinked their cups together in a mock toast.
“To our first Halloween together.” Chase said.
Danny smiled. “To us.”
As the night went on, they danced together. Or rather, Chase danced, and Danny swayed pretending to dance. At one point, the DJ called for a costume contest, and Chase nudged Danny. “You think we’d win if we entered as each other?”
Danny laughed, shaking his head. “I think we’d blow their minds, but I’m happy just watching.”
They leaned against the wall, enjoying the spectacle of wild and creative costumes parading across the makeshift stage. A person dressed as a giant, glittery unicorn won the top prize, much to the crowd’s delight, and Chase and Danny clapped along with everyone else, enjoying the show.
—-
Danny and Chase left the party soon after, and decided to spend the rest of the night watching The Nightmare Before Christmas. Or they would have, if it weren’t for the fog knocking everyone unconscious.