Avatar of Dion

Status

Recent Statuses

6 days ago
Current and y'all were mad i was out here talking about sucking toes. now you're stuck with this guy. hope you're happy, fools.
2 likes
9 days ago
i love your cat more than you btw
9 days ago
not to repeat it ad nauseam but my dating app entry is that i suck toes as long as they're white, baby blue, pink or french tipped
9 days ago
do [img]paste the url here[/img] and it'll work
1 like
9 days ago
used to be a league guy but fortunately i dropped that habit
1 like

Bio

Just an Aragorn looking for his Arwen


Most Recent Posts

@MahouOppai PM, or post in the topic, for the character sheets?
Posting as a show of interest, and to remind myself I want to make a character for this.
It's bump, also, man.
@Vor I agree. I've always thought that free roleplay was indeed more of a time-allocation thing and advanced was simply put, labeled wrongly. They're not more advanced writers per definition (though, often, they are so in practice). I think the 'differentiation between the levels' here comes also from this time commitment.

Simply put, more time spent writing = faster adaptation of good writer = easier to become a good writer. The advanced roleplay tab doesn't indicate solely that if you write there, you're a good writer. I've read many non-good posts in advanced. I don't read much free roleplay, but in casual, I've seen some absolute masterworks. I think a fair part of that is also the interactivity.

Roleplay isn't solely about writing anyway. It's also about interactivity (for me) and understanding story-telling. You can be Tolkien, if you can't work with other people and/or tell a story in an interesting way no matter how good you write it, I'd be inclined to think you're not as good as you write.

As long as people are having fun, though, I think it's all fine. The discussion is growing old for me and frankly I think both sides to this story are just being stupid. Just let people have their playgrounds, right?
It's bump, man.
I'll just come in here and drop an endorsement. That's fucking right.

This guy, ace roleplayer, fo sho.
@MiddleEarthRoze as you said 'You'll also find far more issues in terms of correct grammar and spelling in the free section.' seemed to me like you were implying that they were separate issues, but I see now that you didn't mean that. Either way, point stands.
@MiddleEarthRoze no, I think you are wrong. Correct grammar and spelling are criteria for being a good writer. You don't see Tolkien writing about how 'Legles stab te ork in te fac wit a arow'. They are criteria for your writing skills. For sure. Now the question is how much a given person cares about it and that's how the sections help.

I don't think I should judge people based on how they write, but I am going to judge whether I want to write with them based on that. And that is specifically what the different sections are for, though admittedly, I agreed with Vor on the basis that they should be relabeled to something else. But the fact of the matter is that to me, the different sections help me understand what is expected of me and what I can expect of a given roleplay if I join it within that respective section.

It's not discrimination (lol) or elitism. This is a private website, with private roleplays (as in, they are not for public use, so to speak) and so I find the notion of 'elitism' far fetched here. A GM is not required to give you a reason for not allowing you to join, or kicking you out. It's a matter of practicality and also manners that he does, but he's not required.

The same goes for standards IMHO. If you writ lik dis, chances are you're not going to be an advanced writer, and therefore have no place to complain about not being allowed in because of 'elitism'. It's your own fault, no?

Now I agree that the previously very present notion of 'filthy casuals' was very present in the old days but it's not anymore. If anything, casual roleplay, specifically high casual, is closer to what I'd call 'elitist'. But that's not what we're talking about I think.
@Vor I agree with your bit about the levels - though, I am hesitant in accepting that a guy writing in 'free' with 2 sentences can be a better writer than someone in advanced.

Yes he can be, but he's not showing it. So, I'm inclined to believe that if anything, free roleplay in itself fulfills the tasks it should - taking care of those people who want fast paced back and forth. I'd argue that that is not an indication of skill, but it's a strange coincidence that some of the 'less good' writers are often in free roleplay. So I'd be inclined to think there's at least some correlation.

© 2007-2024
BBCode Cheatsheet