@iHxzardx I think that says more about your personal taste than being a definitive marker of whether or not SAO is a good anime. ;P
I mean it definitely had some enjoyable moments and a few good episodes that I quite liked but honestly the concept deserved so much more than what it got. The plot was kinda eh but my main issue was Kirito and the fact he is about as fulfilling and interesting as a bowl of oatmeal and white rice mixed together and then spent like the rest of the series stroking his dick for no real reason other than "he's a kewl solo play0r who can save us ALL". The rotating string of waifu's who accomplish nothing might have annoyed me but tbh because it was animated by A1 pictures they literally all have the same face so I was convinced it was Asuna in a various collection of cosplay and wigs.
I think what truly did it was when I explained to my boyfriend at the time that I didn't like SAO he was like "NO IT'S GOOD LET ME SHOW YOU" and then made me rewatch in English dub WHICH LET ME TELL YOU WAS A WILD RIDE.