Alright, it may not be the worst film ever, but there's one that crushed my very soul like no other: Gods and Generals. This is a story in two parts. The Build-Up, and The Disaster.
The story of Gods and Generals began more than two decades before a single cell of film was shot, with Michael Shaara's book about the battle of Gettysburg, The Killer Angels. Shaara intended to follow up the Pulitzer Prize novel with a prequel and a sequel, but died before they could be written.
Flash forward a decade to 1990. Despite the fact that there has never been a good battlefield film of the war, and with everyone seeing no reason for this to be any different, Ted Turner has picked up the film rights to the Killer Angels. Utterly unknown director Ron Maxwell is tapped for the project, and while shooting, calls up Michael's son Jeff and asks him to write the never started other two books. Bear in mind at this point that Jeff is a rare coin dealer with no writing experience whatsoever.
Well, beginner's luck seems to be the order of the day. The film Gettysburg is a gigantic success, and Jeff's prequel novel Gods and Generals is regarded as even better than his father's work, sparking the Shaara military history franchise. As soon as the Gods and Generals adaptation is announced, every Civil War nut's thought process is as follows:
"Damn, they got nearly everyone back?? And not only is Stephen Lang returning, he's gonna be Stonewall? Maxwell's still behind the camera? This whole trilogy seems to be blessed by God himself! Holy shit, this might even top Gettysburg!"
Flash forward a decade to 1990. Despite the fact that there has never been a good battlefield film of the war, and with everyone seeing no reason for this to be any different, Ted Turner has picked up the film rights to the Killer Angels. Utterly unknown director Ron Maxwell is tapped for the project, and while shooting, calls up Michael's son Jeff and asks him to write the never started other two books. Bear in mind at this point that Jeff is a rare coin dealer with no writing experience whatsoever.
Well, beginner's luck seems to be the order of the day. The film Gettysburg is a gigantic success, and Jeff's prequel novel Gods and Generals is regarded as even better than his father's work, sparking the Shaara military history franchise. As soon as the Gods and Generals adaptation is announced, every Civil War nut's thought process is as follows:
"Damn, they got nearly everyone back?? And not only is Stephen Lang returning, he's gonna be Stonewall? Maxwell's still behind the camera? This whole trilogy seems to be blessed by God himself! Holy shit, this might even top Gettysburg!"
However, there was one major problem: For Gettysburg, Maxwell had not needed to do anything with the home front. In fact, there is a single line from a civilian in the entire 4 hour plus film. Half of Gods and Generals was non-military scenes, and he simply was terrible with them. In addition, not using the incredible main theme from Gettysburg at all was a massive mistake, and Lang, the major star, never found his footing. The end result was what could have been a great and quite frankly needed film franchise dead in the cradle. C'est la vie.