Spirit: The first couple of paragraphs; we have nothing to add to. The weapon is the discussion we'll continue though.
Spirit: I like the idea of the removing the gun transformation entirely though and putting the head on a chain to use as a flail/grappling hook. Variety is the spice of life and all that jazz.
Phantom:Might I suggest something a bit more fluid than a maul family weapon? Perhaps an italian longsword? or a basket hilted sword, such as a Schiavona?
Spirit:We never said anything about weight. We said that the head of a Becs de Corbin is too small to hold all the moving parts needed to condense the weapon into a beretta, and suggested a larger head, which would actually add more weight to it.
Phantom:OOH! perfect weapon. A partisan, it's a form of polearm, very fancy looking, sharp metal cap opposite the blade. sort of a realy decorative spear...
Spirit: Very ceremonial these days. The yeoman of the guard in England still use them.
Phantom:ceremonial=elegant, amiright?
Spirit: More fluid movements, i think, than the weight-driven hammer. Though the traditional Becs de Corbin that he used would probably be the same amount of fluidity, if it's a small head, which means he'd have to remove the gun form like he was saying. The chain thing would just be a long flail type thing...
Phantom:A partisan can also be used with a small shield, maybe integrate an SMG or hotgun with a buckler?
Spirit: So, something like what Pyrrha uses?
Phantom:Hers is just a plain old shield, only special use is with her polarity.
Spirit: Hmmm. Methinks we are going around in circles.
Phantom:How is makig a new suggestion going in circles?
Spirit:Because...I don't know. It feels like we are.
Phantom:If it's about removing the gun, a ranged mode is good to have, but doesn't flow very well, so remove it and reintegrate using a small shield.
Spirit: Ohhh. Right. Yep. Good idea.
Phantom:Weapons are kind of my thing, you know?
Spirit: I like people. Does that mean it's mine? Lol
Phantom:Well, there is your fiance...
Spirit:...? We'll probably have to trim this...
Phantom:Oh, yeah, definitely. but whatever, more fun this way.Spirit: Yes, yes it is. Moving on! Suggestion for the weapon is: keep the Becs de Corbin and remove the gun form like you said, and integrate it into a buckler - possibly using a shotgun with some sort of spray ammo rather than a carbine for the firearm portion.
Spirit: On the background. Blake was part of a peaceful activist group that turned violent three years ago - when she was fourteen. Her parents were also apparently part of it when they presumably died (we don't actually know) so it could be said that the peaceful White Fang raised her.
Phantom:And like she said, if you can't fight you can't survive outside the kingdoms, so she fought.
Spirit: I can understand if the main target of the hate acid is her mum, who got hurt by the acid and then she got splashed by it, though I still think only one eye would have been damaged - her mum would have started turning away when she saw the acid coming, or even felt it hit her, and would clutch her tighter to her chest meaning she would be a bit more protected from it hitting her face.
Phantom:Why acid, though? why not just naturally blind? it's not a requirement to be abusive to your characters, you know. I removed that part.
Spirit: Especially if it happened when she was a baby anyway - she wouldn't miss being able to see if she was born blind, and would give her parents enough reason to still be overprotective of her.
Phantom:On the topic of realism in RWBY weapons, however;
LET ME EXPLAIN YOU A THING!
Phantom:All weapons in RWBY are complete, functional 3d models, no parts clip into eachother, and none spontaneously appear. the atlesian paladin? all 1 coherant model. guns folding up so the hands can come out? all the parts were already there.
Remember one thing about Crescent Rose, the person using it isn't a normal person, having aura unlocked is strongly implied to grant superhuman abilities, and Ruby is a specialist who ONLY knows how to use that 1 ridiculous weapon. implausible? Oh hell yes. unrealistic? not as much as you would think.
Spirit: Ballet is actually a pretty rigid dance - not as fluid as you might think. yeah, it's got fluid arm sweeps and little hops and cutesy little things in it, and looks really nice when it's all put together, but if you stray even an inch out of form it completely ruins the whole effect.
Phantom:legs stay pretty straight if I recall, never gotten involved, avoided it like the plague, but I've seen picture and video.
Spirit: I learnt some in high school for dance class. A more fluid dance would be contemporary.
Phantom:Something latin, like salsa, that shit is all over the place.
Spirit: That kind of thing requires a partner though, and the partners actually support a lot of the body weight of the other person, which is what allows them to do their crazy moves.
Phantom:Imagine someone killing a Beowulf by using it as a dance partner.
Spirit:...oh God, she's going to Foxtrot them all over the field.
Phantom: What style of dance goes with that song Livin' La Vida Loca?
Spirit: Uh. Latino I believe.
Phantpm:That involves some weird spin thing I think, combine that with a sword of some description.
Spirit:Most waltzes have spins and stuff in them. She could be a student of many, master of none type of dancer - have the core strength for ballet, but combine it with some of the weird stuff you get with hip hop, latino, salsa, rumba, flamenco, contemporary, some of the ballet moves themselves.
Phantom:Many forms of swordplay are pretty dance like.
Spirit: A rapier fencing instructor I know actually suggests to his students to go learn the pavane, along with many types of waltzes to help with their footwork.
Phantom:They say fancy footwork, and they mean it.
Spirit: Yeah, rapier is the most dancelike form of swordplay there is - you really don't get more dancerish with any other kind of weapon (other than maybe war fans or the spinny ribbon things that people light on fire, starts with a p)