Hidden 9 yrs ago 9 yrs ago Post by mdk
Raw

mdk 3/4

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

I just finished Damocles, and now I need some time to brood before I review things. Tonight! I hope. Unless I turn lazy again.

edit: I turned lazy again. First thing tomorrow, pinky swear.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by mdk
Raw

mdk 3/4

Member Seen 6 yrs ago













End of the day, I can't help it -- @vote for @Keyguyperson, because my god, that was absolutely incredible.
1x Thank Thank
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Loksfjoer
Raw
Avatar of Loksfjoer

Loksfjoer Lucky flame

Contest Mod Seen 9 hrs ago

I have read everything now. Time for a word of feedback and the most difficult part: the vote.

So, I'm going to skip grammatical feedback. Going over the stories I didn't see any grammatical errors, but that doesn't mean they aren't any. I tend to read over small mistakes. I hope the feedback will be good enough. If anyone has additional questions, feel free to ask them.











My @vote is for @Keyguyperson. While I prefer lighter happy-ending stories, I can't deny this story is of high quality.
1x Thank Thank
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Dedonus
Raw
Avatar of Dedonus

Dedonus Kai su teknon;

Member Seen 1 mo ago

@mdk@WiseDragonGirl

Fair analyses. It is my own fault for using genre-specific terms and assuming that the reader would assume an X-Men-like hatred towards people who are different. I agree I could have made Kyra look more surprised, or rather made it more clear that her metahuman status = her fox-like appearance.

Also, fyi:
Metahuman = anyone with superpowers.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by mdk
Raw

mdk 3/4

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

@wisedragongirl -- the home invader wasn't *really* a tree, it was a homeless guy with camo pants. The idea was to tell it in the same way the kid would've been seeing it, like in a nightmare, because yeah he's completely and totally traumatized by it and has no way of making sense of anything. I get the 'confusing' note a lot when I do stuff like this, and I should've learned my lesson by now.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Dedonus
Raw
Avatar of Dedonus

Dedonus Kai su teknon;

Member Seen 1 mo ago

@wisedragongirl -- the home invader wasn't *really* a tree, it was a homeless guy with camo pants. The idea was to tell it in the same way the kid would've been seeing it, like in a nightmare, because yeah he's completely and totally traumatized by it and has no way of making sense of anything. I get the 'confusing' note a lot when I do stuff like this, and I should've learned my lesson by now.


I too did not get a crazy homeless guy out of that either.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Loksfjoer
Raw
Avatar of Loksfjoer

Loksfjoer Lucky flame

Contest Mod Seen 9 hrs ago

@wisedragongirl -- the home invader wasn't *really* a tree, it was a homeless guy with camo pants. The idea was to tell it in the same way the kid would've been seeing it, like in a nightmare, because yeah he's completely and totally traumatized by it and has no way of making sense of anything. I get the 'confusing' note a lot when I do stuff like this, and I should've learned my lesson by now.


You were definitely able to get a clear image through the child's eyes across with your writing, I really pictured large living monstrous trees entering the home while crazy homeless guy does make sense, in horror stories any kind of monsters possible so I didn't think the idea of evil trees was that far-fetched.
1x Like Like
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by mdk
Raw

mdk 3/4

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

<Snipped quote by mdk>

You were definitely able to get a clear image through the child's eyes across with your writing, I really pictured large living monstrous trees entering the home while crazy homeless guy does make sense, in horror stories any kind of monsters possible so I didn't think the idea of evil trees was that far-fetched.


I mean, Homeless Guy is who the police probably would've arrested in this story, but maybe the walking tree just got away with murder.
1x Like Like
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Loksfjoer
Raw
Avatar of Loksfjoer

Loksfjoer Lucky flame

Contest Mod Seen 9 hrs ago

I didn't enter the 4th round, so I don't know how it was there, but the voting for this round seems less exciting then the first 3 rounds...
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Keyguyperson
Raw
Avatar of Keyguyperson

Keyguyperson Welcome to Cyberhell

Member Seen 6 mos ago

I didn't enter the 4th round, so I don't know how it was there, but the voting for this round seems less exciting then the first 3 rounds...


Yeah, I'd feel good about winning with 100% support, but I feel like people just aren't voting for some reason. Which is probably true. I hope we get a surge the day before or the day of closing, it happened before.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Dedonus
Raw
Avatar of Dedonus

Dedonus Kai su teknon;

Member Seen 1 mo ago

I @vote for @Dedonus (i.e. myself)
Hopefully I am not breaking the rules by voting for myself. If I am, I can change it...
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Loksfjoer
Raw
Avatar of Loksfjoer

Loksfjoer Lucky flame

Contest Mod Seen 9 hrs ago

In this thread there aren't any voting rules specified as far as I can see, but I assumed we were supposed to vote for an entry other than our own. In this thread it states that you must have read everything and then vote for the story you liked best. I feel my story was good enough to vote for myself (while Keyguyperson's story really is of good quality, it's not the kind of story I generally enjoy reading), but I don't think that's how the voting is supposed to work. That could be just me of course, in the end that is up to @mdk.

@Keyguyperson getting 100% of the votes is a good feeling, even if it is just 2/2 ^_^ That still means the two people who read it felt it was the best.
You really should tell me what those Chinese guys said to each other. Google translate was no help at all.

In general, I'm glad I was able to make some time and read all the entries this time. Of course there weren't that many entries in this round, that helped. I have the utmost respect for everyone who gave feedback on every story in the previous rounds when there were even more entries.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Keyguyperson
Raw
Avatar of Keyguyperson

Keyguyperson Welcome to Cyberhell

Member Seen 6 mos ago

Oh yeah, I still haven't done that.

What the Chinese soldiers said is actually pretty straightforward. I don't remember the actual translation, and google translate doesn't help because I used the romanizations, but I remembered the gist of it. Basically, the first one was about to shoot Niall (which we know), but the other one came running after he heard that the missiles had been launched. His screams startled the first one, and was simply "Stop! Stop!" if my memory is correct. Luckily for Niall, his surprise made him miss, after which the second soldier tells the first that the missiles have been launched, then says "It's all over". The first is confused, and continually asks why. The second one says he doesn't know (Again, if I remember correctly), and just starts saying "It's over, it's over". Orders to not shoot are given, and the first one asks "Why not kill him? He did this to us!". The second says that it wasn't him who turned the key, and that everyone is a victim at this point.

There are probably a few problems with the order I put things in here, but that's more or less what happened.
1x Thank Thank
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by mdk
Raw

mdk 3/4

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

In this thread there aren't any voting rules specified as far as I can see, but I assumed we were supposed to vote for an entry other than our own. In this thread it states that you must have read everything and then vote for the story you liked best. I feel my story was good enough to vote for myself (while Keyguyperson's story really is of good quality, it's not the kind of story I generally enjoy reading), but I don't think that's how the voting is supposed to work. That could be just me of course, in the end that is up to @mdk.


It's allowed, and at the same time, we hope you don't. Being totally happy with your own writing is not a great way to get better at it -- and that's what we're really trying to do here.

We're not going to stop people from voting for themselves unless that starts to ruin the contest. But we hope that everyone can look at other people's writing objectively and congratulate them on jobs well done.
Hidden 9 yrs ago 9 yrs ago Post by ayzrules
Raw
Avatar of ayzrules

ayzrules CEO of staying up all night

Member Seen 3 mos ago

"Fǒu! Fǒu!"

The screaming came with the sound of more rustling leaves, and the next thing he knew, there was a gunshot. He closed his eyes at the sound, fully expecting to die instantly. He didn't feel anything though. For a moment, he wondered if the universe was merciful enough to take away the pain of death.

"Tāmen tuīchū hé dǎodàn! Jiéshùle!" Said the same man who had been screaming earlier.

The gunshot had made it clear that they were soldiers, but Niall had no idea what they were saying. He didn't know a word of Chinese, for all he knew, they could be discussing whether to kill him or take him prisoner.

"Hé dǎodàn?" Asked the man who Niall thought was the first soldier to find him. His voice was quivering, hopefully a sign that he wasn't going to shoot again. "W-wèishéme ne? Tāmen wèishéme yào nàme zuò ne?"

"Měiguó tuīchū tāmen de, ránhòu èluósī. Jiéshùle, jiéshùle..." At this point, the man was clearly in tears. Not happy ones either, he was devastated. It wasn't the voice of a man who had failed his mission, it was the voice of a man who had just seen everything he loved burnt to dust before him.

"Wèishéme ne?"

"Wǒ bù zhīdào! Zhǐyào bù shāle tā!"

"Wèishéme ne?" Yelled the other man, less sorrowful and more angry. "Tāmen shāle wǒmen suǒyǒu rén! Měi gèrén! Tāmen shāle dàjiā!"

"Tā méiyǒu zuò dào zhè yīdiǎn! Zhè shì tā de zhèngfǔ, méiyǒu rén huì xiǎng zhège! Bǎ qiāng fàngxià!"


That awkward moment when you're not supposed to know what the people are saying but you know how to speak chinese :D

and pardon me if i'm wrong, but i think (in the exact order) it's something like:
no! no! they launched the nuclear missiles! it's over!
the nuclear missile? why? why would they do that?
america launched them, and then russia. it's over, it's over...
why?
i don't know! as long as they don't kill him
why? they killed all of our people! every person! they killed everyone!
he didn't do this! it was his government. put the gun down!

*this is not directly translated, more like interpreted*

Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Keyguyperson
Raw
Avatar of Keyguyperson

Keyguyperson Welcome to Cyberhell

Member Seen 6 mos ago

<Snipped quote>

That awkward moment when you're not supposed to know what the people are saying but you know how to speak chinese :D

and pardon me if i'm wrong, but i think (in the exact order) it's something like:
no! no! they launched the nuclear missiles! it's over!
the nuclear missile? why? why would they do that?
america launched them, and then russia. it's over, it's over...
why?
i don't know! as long as they don't kill him
why? they killed all of our people! every person! they killed everyone!
he didn't do this! it was his government. put the gun down!

*this is not directly translated, more like interpreted*


That seems about right, I'm honestly surprised you actually managed to get something out of it. Because nobody I know knows Chinese, so I used Google Translate. Nice to know it's somewhat coherent.
Hidden 9 yrs ago 9 yrs ago Post by ayzrules
Raw
Avatar of ayzrules

ayzrules CEO of staying up all night

Member Seen 3 mos ago

<Snipped quote by ayzrules>

That seems about right, I'm honestly surprised you actually managed to get something out of it. Because nobody I know knows Chinese, so I used Google Translate. Nice to know it's somewhat coherent.


I mean i thought the use of the "fou" was weird, because people would normally say "bu" for no but you know what it's google translate lol

but yeah it makes some sense :D

if u wanted to put it into google translate yourself:
否否!
他们推出核导弹!结束了!
核导弹?为什么呢?他们为什么要那么做呢?
美国推出他们的, 然后俄罗斯。 结束了, 结束了
为什么?
我不知道!只要不杀了他!
为什么?他们杀了我们所有人!每个人!他们杀了大家!
他没有做到这一点!这是他的政府, 没有人会像这个!把枪放下!
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Holmishire
Raw

Holmishire Ghost with no home.

Member Seen 2 mos ago

I've been caught in a constant—and still ongoing—stream of midterms and large projects, so I haven't been able to devote a lot of time here this month. I apologize, for my reviews won't receive nearly as much attention as I normally give them.

>C+


>C+


>B-


>C+


>B+


>B+


I @vote for the Trees. Now to read the rest of the thread, and then glorious sleep.
2x Thank Thank
Hidden 9 yrs ago 9 yrs ago Post by mdk
Raw

mdk 3/4

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

Voting is now closed!

This was a low-volume contest, but certainly not a weak one -- contained here are some of my favorite RPGC entries of all time, and I get the feeling they'll stand up for a long time that way. These were INCREDIBLE, and if you haven't read them yet, you really should -- top to bottom, great job, and that's coming from the heart.

Because of the low volume, and the new thing we tried with bonuses that didn't really pan out, the trophies for this contest are gonna work a little different. Luckily, we do have a clear-cut winner of the open vote, so that part's normal, but in this weird instance, both runners-up are sorta self-awarding, and I feel like the Fonz-er move is to advance the 'second place'-ish trophy to the consensus staff-pick, because that was unanimous. So, without further ado:

Winner: 'Damocles' by @Keyguyperson!


I've probably said enough about how good this was by now, but let's say it again for good measure -- a total picture of mankind's truest nightmare, and a chilling one at that.

Staff Choice: 'The Elevator' by @WiseDragonGirl!


This simple narrative was optimistic and very well-written, and creatively subversive on the "Fear" theme. We simply love it.

Runners-up


'Kitsune' by @dedonus. Does a lot of things very right, and showcases some clear development as a writer. You're on the right track, [@deadonus]!

'The Trees' by @mdk. I guess I'd call it a supremely dark look through the eyes of a child, and reviewers agree it was chilling, if a little confusing at times.

And Remember!


The Fifth Labor is coming tonight! @Terminal's contest is absolutely fantastic -- if you haven't checked it out yet, you're doing it wrong! Find the conversation thread here and stand by for another chapter in the running challenge.

LOOKING AHEAD


Next month is November, and November is National Novel Writing Month! I absolutely swear by this marathon writing challenge. RPGC is scheming to incorporate NaNoWriMo participants into our prize pool. You should totally give it a try -- but whether you choose to NaNo or not, we'll have another RPGC coming in November.

Congratulations to all, and thanks!
2x Thank Thank
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Dedonus
Raw
Avatar of Dedonus

Dedonus Kai su teknon;

Member Seen 1 mo ago

Runners-up


'Kitsune' by @Dedonus. Does a lot of things very right, and showcases some clear development as a writer. You're on the right track, @Dedonus!


Thanks for the acknowledgement! Isn't it one of the reasons why we're doing this, to get feedback on our writing? One thing I tried to get right was to write a story that could be self-contained, rather than something that probably would have been more suited for being a chapter of a longer work.

Edit: Also, you misspelled my name. There is no "a" in "Dedonus".
↑ Top
© 2007-2024
BBCode Cheatsheet