1 Guest viewing this page
Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 10 hrs ago

@Salty Spitoon
Mae looks fine to me, albeit you might wanna mention something about her having clothes or shoes... Unless you intended to have her walk around buck-nekkid. I mean, I'm not opposed to the idea in any way, just bringing it up in case that wasn't your plan.
Also, I'm assuming the things you've listed as "Skills" are her passives? It also looks like the description for 'Chi Strike' was lost, or cut, halfway through, so I don't really know what it actually does.

But, overall she looks fine and dandy, and we're happy to have ourselves a squealing little monk-lass who'll probably chase Branwen around, trying to hug her, for the forseeable future. Welcome, and go ahead and add her to the character tab. :)
Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by Reia
Raw
Avatar of Reia

Reia

Member Seen 5 yrs ago

I just noticed that my character's Keen Senses ability is really similar to yours, and you designed your character first @Afro Samurai - would you like me to change my character up a bit so there's more distinction between them, or do you think it's okay if there's some overlap there?
Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by ZEDDOILO
Raw

ZEDDOILO

Member Seen 5 yrs ago



Ill lower that stats if need be.
Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 10 hrs ago

@ZEDDOILO
Hello and welcome. Sadly, I'm afraid Neir is not acceptable as a character. There are many reasons why this is, but I'll try to list as many as I can, as neatly as I can, and you can decide whether you want to edit and fix these things, or try making a different character entirely.

So, let's begin.

1. The most glaring issue is that Neir is portrayed as incredibly powerful and capable. This is rather unfitting, as he is a Level 20 individual, who is roughly on par in terms of power to an average Orc Warrior, or in case of humans, slightly better than a standard soldier with training in a regular army. The feats and powers that Neir would need in order to pull off the things he has done does not fit with his actual level.

2. It seems Neir belongs to a family that has power over three continents. I'm not sure if you mistook continents for provinces, because a continent is a very larghe place - and if they have power over three of them, that would mean they had power over several other nations, kingdoms and empires - which I seriosuly doubt they could.

3. Neir's history does not seem to add up. He was a prodigy who was essentially betrayed by his parents to become an assassin. he was then broken mentally and brainwashed to become a puppet - which would squander any mental gifts or impressive academic faculties he may have had - so as to become a trained killer. He was then used to kill his parents, who attempted to curse him to prevent this, but the curse changed because of his mind and became something else... And THEN, that curse for some reason caused an experiment to make him regain his consciousness and will, which sent him into a berserker rage - even though his Personality-part states that he's cold, calm and always in control. I'm sorry, but curses don't work that way, they don't change depending on a person's mind or mental state. And how could there be a ritual that caused him to regain his self awareness, when his parents attempted the curse while being attacked by him and in a panic? Were they aware of how the Order operated and what experiments they were doing, and so could plan ahead and lay a trap so that Neir would destroy the Order after he killed them? That seems very unlikely too, as there was no mention in the history that his parents ever had any dealings with the Order prior to sending their own son there...

4. Neir is an Arcane Assassin, but there's no mention of spellcraft or arcane studies in his history. It is also stated that he is incredibly patient and can wait decades for a plan to work out... But he's a human... ANd he's 19 years old... How does that add up? I mean, sure, if you meant is a metaphor and as something that would be the case in a future, hypothetical scenario, sure. But it still seems odd.

5. A "Strategist" is not a Hand-to-Hand fighter, they're people who plan and calculate how to best use tools, resources and manpower to achieve victory over an opponent. This seems like a very odd skill for an assassin to have, as assassins do not lead large forces or groups, but rather as singular individuals focused on murdering specific other individuals.

6. He is listed as a savvy businessman, but there is no mention of him receiving training, education or having had any contact with merchants and/or traders of any sort. Also, this again seems like an odd thing for an assassin to have, as they typically just take a predetermined sum of money which is - typically - based on the difficulty of eliniating their target.

7. Given his personality, mannerisms and mental state, I find it hard to see an individual such as this joining up with a random group of strangers, who most likely will not have any interest in becoming hired killers or executioners of some self-imposed sense of justice and order. I don't mind gloomy, stoic or unsocial characters, they're usually some of my favorites in other media, but in a roleplay they tend to not work very well, because if you're not intereacting with others,. they won't likely interact much with you

There are other minor issues, but these are the most blatant issues I have with the character. He simply seems too strong, too powerful, too good and skilled at everything and has several contradictory elements to him.
Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by The Irish Tree
Raw
Avatar of The Irish Tree

The Irish Tree Hot-Blooded Loser

Member Seen 3 hrs ago



DUMBASS COMIN' THROUGH!

Backstory might be a bit rough, but I'll change anything that needs changing!
Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by ERode
Raw
Avatar of ERode

ERode A Spiny Ant

Member Online

My intent for Storm's Boon (as well as Zephyrus Aria) was that, as Spellblade-specific spells, they would function as buffs that can turn into active spells (lightning spear explosion, wind barrier explosion) at the cost of requiring the buff to be re-cast afterwards. I'll set Storm's Boon to a not-big explosion though, no problemo.

Just so I have a clearer idea of how Stats function, the formula is actually something like Stats x Level = Actual Numeric Value of Power, right? So your grade on your stat is more of a modifier, rather than an absolute indication of how prodigious your capabilities are, and it grows at a much slower pace than your level would?

So at max level, you still wouldn't be at the point where you naturally have S-rank in all stats?
Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 10 hrs ago

Fair enough.

And yes, that's exactly how stats work. They're an indication of your rough capabilities and are more meant to indicate what yuo excel (or suffer) at, rather than being a set, numeric value. Your stats when levelling up will not change, as such, level is a better indicator of overall strength than stats - as only stats of two beings of the exact same level are really comparable to begin with.

Now to read the Tree's CS.
Hidden 5 yrs ago 5 yrs ago Post by DELETED08740
Raw

DELETED08740

Banned Seen 1 mo ago

Posting my submission!


Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by Afro Samurai
Raw
Avatar of Afro Samurai

Afro Samurai Like a Raisin in the Sun

Member Seen 1 yr ago

I just noticed that my character's Keen Senses ability is really similar to yours, and you designed your character first @Afro Samurai - would you like me to change my character up a bit so there's more distinction between them, or do you think it's okay if there's some overlap there?


nah its good (i didnt see this tag for some reason lmaoo) i think it'll be useful for the party in the long run. overlap is wonderful in my eyes. plus, they're very different in other respects and branwen is too cold as is to be changed!
Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 10 hrs ago

@The Irish Tree
Vani Silverstream is accepted, go post the dumbass in the character tab... Gods, this'll be a disaster... xD

Now on to Pigeon's sheet!
1x Like Like 1x Laugh Laugh
Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by Click This
Raw
Avatar of Click This

Click This Part-time Kaiserin

Member Seen 13 hrs ago

Yo, Xalt. Long time no see. If you're still considering sheets I might have something for you later.
Hidden 5 yrs ago 5 yrs ago Post by Salty Spitoon
Raw
Avatar of Salty Spitoon

Salty Spitoon

Member Seen 4 yrs ago

@Salty Spitoon
Mae looks fine to me, albeit you might wanna mention something about her having clothes or shoes... Unless you intended to have her walk around buck-nekkid. I mean, I'm not opposed to the idea in any way, just bringing it up in case that wasn't your plan.
Also, I'm assuming the things you've listed as "Skills" are her passives? It also looks like the description for 'Chi Strike' was lost, or cut, halfway through, so I don't really know what it actually does.

But, overall she looks fine and dandy, and we're happy to have ourselves a squealing little monk-lass who'll probably chase Branwen around, trying to hug her, for the forseeable future. Welcome, and go ahead and add her to the character tab. :)


Definitely 1,000% nekkid at all times :P

I kid, I will add clothes for modesty's sake.

And yeah, I was adding skills and how they were lining up where more along the lines of skills (passives) she has learned over her lifetime. So I thought I would break it up into skills (passives) and abilities (performed attacks/buffs).

And for the cut off ability. Yeah, I noticed that shortly after posting. I had fixed it, but you may not have looked at it again after my edit :P But it's entirety is there now. And I think I also added another ability during that edit.
1x Laugh Laugh
Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by Salty Spitoon
Raw
Avatar of Salty Spitoon

Salty Spitoon

Member Seen 4 yrs ago

@Xaltwind
ALSO! I wrote Chi Strike wrong, it's fixed now though. Chi Strike either pools Chi Energy in her hands OR her legs. Not both.
1x Like Like
Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 10 hrs ago

@PigeonOfAstora
Ciel Lalune is 'toes accepted, go ahead and post him in the character tab.

@Click This
Well now, there's someone I didn't expect to see. How the heck are ya, ya old goaat? ^^
You're very free to submit a CS, provided your old bones can keep up with the post-once-a-week rule.

Good to see you're still around. :D

@Salty Spitoon
NUUUUUUUUUUUU! WHY YU RUIN A GOOD THING!? ... I mean, err... Good! Nekkid is... shameful.. Yes... Prudence and modesty are good things... *cough*
1x Laugh Laugh
Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by ERode
Raw
Avatar of ERode

ERode A Spiny Ant

Member Online

How many people were you planning on accepting total anyways, Xalt?
Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 10 hrs ago

That being said...


As of now, with the exception of @Click This, this roleplay is now currently FULL and we won't be accepting new applicants until/if a spot becomes vacant.

Thank you to alll who've joined and who expressed interest in this.

The actual story should begin shortly... If I can just get my ass in gear and finish up my own damn character...
3x Like Like
Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by OwO
Raw
Avatar of OwO

OwO what's this?

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

As of now, with the exception of Click This, this roleplay is now currently FULL and we won't be accepting new applicants until/if a spot becomes vacant.


Wait, for absolutely everyone even if they put a character in the interest check?
1x Laugh Laugh
Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 10 hrs ago

No, of course not. Go ahead and submit your full sheet here, I'll review it and then we'll go foom there.

To be perfectly honest, not only did I forget that you made a character, OwO, but I also didn't think you'd come along for the ride. Guess that's what I get for forgetting about time zones...
1x Thank Thank
Hidden 5 yrs ago Post by Asuras
Raw
Avatar of Asuras

Asuras No spoken words, only napalm and guns

Member Seen 1 day ago

I'll put my name down for a waitlist then, if that's at all possible.
1x Like Like
Hidden 5 yrs ago 5 yrs ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 10 hrs ago

I'll put my name down for a waitlist then, if that's at all possible.

That's totally fine. I'll PM if you a spot ever becomes available. :)

EDIT:

I added a Waitlist to the 0th post of this OOC, in case we get more people interested.
↑ Top
1 Guest viewing this page
© 2007-2024
BBCode Cheatsheet