[OOC] Heroes of Beacon - the Next Chapter

[SevenStormStyle]

I'm such a dub noob. ;_;

Fate/Zero has gotta be one of the best, though.

[harinezumikouken]

I'm such a dub noob. ;_;

Fate/Zero has gotta be one of the best, though.

@SevenStormStyle

To each their own.

I really need to finish the visual novel and start watching the Fate series. I still know jack shit in regards to that anime and everyone keeps saying how good it is.

[Krayzikk]

Hey @HereComesTheSnow I permit friendly joshing but a contingency of similarly-themed posts is more like harassment. Plank, you can't demonize RT for not 'going all out casting this'. RWBY was a startup project of a little studio in Texas, they didn't get the luxury of nabbing the best voice actors in the business. Personally, I don't give a crap about who voices it in Japanse; it'll never be anything more than charming for me because I don't understand Japanese. If you two feel like puffing yourselves up about the superiority your opinions by jumping down someone's throat for their personal opinion (which will doubtlessly include mine now) then you can take it to PMs and have a stroke-fest there. This discussion is over.

@Lugubrious

So wait

I'm confused

How is ending the argument with easily the most inflammatory statements in the argument better than 'a contingent of similarly themed posts' (contingent, for the record, doesn't mean 'two'. That'd be the worst contingent of all time), when the person responding to that contingent of posts (Three, for the record, and slightly higher if you're being generous with where the argument started) compares the people expressing a perfectly valid viewpoint to Nazis?

One one side, we have a relatively civil (aside from one picture) analysis of why the dub won't suck; not "English version sucks", just that the Japanese one won't. And in fact, by your own reasoning, does have a better VA cast. On the other side we have comparisons to Nazis, scathing comments about opinions, and telling your players to go have a stroke-fest in their own PMs. In a manner intended to end it.

So yeah.

I'm confused where you've got the moral high ground. But GM privilege means you get to end that line of thought right there, so.

[Lugubrious]

<Snipped quote by Lugubrious>

So wait

I'm confused

How is ending the argument with easily the most inflammatory statements in the argument better than 'a contingent of similarly themed posts' (contingent, for the record, doesn't mean 'two'. That'd be the worst contingent of all time), when the person responding to that contingent of posts (Three, for the record, and slightly higher if you're being generous with where the argument started) compares the people expressing a perfectly valid viewpoint to Nazis?

One one side, we have a relatively civil (aside from one picture) analysis of why the dub won't suck; not "English version sucks", just that the Japanese one won't. And in fact, by your own reasoning, does have a better VA cast. On the other side we have comparisons to Nazis, scathing comments about opinions, and telling your players to go have a stroke-fest in their own PMs. In a manner intended to end it.

So yeah.

I'm confused where you've got the moral high ground. But GM privilege means you get to end that line of thought right there, so.

@Krayzikk

Good lord, man. You just keep digging yourself deeper.

Well your taste is consistently shit, I'll give you that.

Yeah, that's civil. Those comments were in response to Forsythe saying that he preferred the English one by the way, not an affirmation that the Japanese one won't suck. The idea that the Japanese dub (objective viewpoint) has better actors wasn't even a point of contention, both Forsythe and I acknowledged that to be fact. It was the idea that Forsythe liked the English one anyway that caused this uproar. It wasn't the objective side of the issue that was being argued; it was the personal side. It wasn't civil or an analysis, it was 'your opinions are wrong and what you like is crap'. I don't care about moral high ground; if it had been an actual debate that was causing controversy, I would have asked it to end in a more sophisticated manner. But it wasn't, so I decided that I was going to end something nasty with a nasty comment.

[Plank Sinatra]

But you've only seen two minutes of the dub, in trailer form, and only heard four cast members. You're letting dub prejudice - which a lot of people do rightly have for a lot of productions - get in the way of what is, objectively, a much better voice cast than the Rooster Teeth circle.

He's just saying you're jumping the gun. Which you are.

not sure where at any point i was crapping on his opinion, or adopted anything but a "wait and see" attitude, but i really didn't even want krayz to let this continue, so

whatever

let it go bruh it's too late for us

[Lucius Cypher]

[Lugubrious]

<Snipped quote>

<Snipped quote>

not sure where at any point i was crapping on his opinion, or adopted anything but a "wait and see" attitude, but i really didn't even want krayz to let this continue, so

whatever

let it go bruh it's too late for us

@Plank Sinatra

Aw, I don't want you to feel too down. I was getting onto Here more than you; you did keep it businesslike. Technically, if you were arguing in favor of the Japanese dub to be objectively better, you were proven correct, so there's that at least.

[HereComesTheSnow]

<Snipped quote by Lugubrious>

So wait

I'm confused

How is ending the argument with easily the most inflammatory statements in the argument better than 'a contingent of similarly themed posts' (contingent, for the record, doesn't mean 'two'. That'd be the worst contingent of all time), when the person responding to that contingent of posts (Three, for the record, and slightly higher if you're being generous with where the argument started) compares the people expressing a perfectly valid viewpoint to Nazis?

One one side, we have a relatively civil (aside from one picture) analysis of why the dub won't suck; not "English version sucks", just that the Japanese one won't. And in fact, by your own reasoning, does have a better VA cast. On the other side we have comparisons to Nazis, scathing comments about opinions, and telling your players to go have a stroke-fest in their own PMs. In a manner intended to end it.

So yeah.

I'm confused where you've got the moral high ground. But GM privilege means you get to end that line of thought right there, so.

@Krayzikk

Come on buddy I called his taste shit to his face

No matter how you slice it that's an insult

[SevenStormStyle]

<Snipped quote by SevenStormStyle>

To each their own.

I really need to finish the visual novel and start watching the Fate series. I still know jack shit in regards to that anime and everyone keeps saying how good it is.

@harinezumikouken

I've never played the visual novel or seen any other entries to the fate series besides Carnival Phantasm, so in the grand scheme of things, I don't know anything either.

[HereComesTheSnow]

i have friends who like fate and i know a few ebin maymays

[Guess Who]

<Snipped quote by SevenStormStyle>

To each their own.

I really need to finish the visual novel and start watching the Fate series. I still know jack shit in regards to that anime and everyone keeps saying how good it is.

@harinezumikouken

Same. I think I left off at some point during the fight with Berserker... Maybe... I don't know anymore, it's been too long. I'll probably need to start from the beginning again.

[KabenSaal]

Rude But Awesome F/SN

(Have to click 'view image' to see it properly)

[harinezumikouken]

<Snipped quote by harinezumikouken>

Same. I think I left off at some point during the fight with Berserker... Maybe... I don't know anymore, it's been too long. I'll probably need to start from the beginning again.

@Guess Who

I'm still at the first like few scenes. Like literally at the first few scenes of the first chapter.

[Guess Who]

Just finished Code Geass, and I have to say, "Holy shit that ending!" Why'd no one tell me about this show earlier?

[harinezumikouken]

Just finished Code Geass, and I have to say, "Holy shit that ending!" Why'd no one tell me about this show earlier?

@Guess Who

Dat ending tho. Dem feels.

[KabenSaal]

Just finished Code Geass, and I have to say, "Holy shit that ending!" Why'd no one tell me about this show earlier?

@Guess Who

Yes, YES, YES! Code Geass is amazing! I love the dubs as well.

(Have you watched R2 as well?)

[Lady Seraphina]

Now tell me this, was he actually dead at the end or did he inherit his father's code?

[Eklispe]

Nobody knows. Even with cannon statements people still disagree lol.

[Guess Who]

<Snipped quote by Guess Who>

Yes, YES, YES! Code Geass is amazing! I love the dubs as well.

(Have you watched R2 as well?)

@KabenSaal

I usually watch dubs, but this time I watched the sub. A friend told me that the dub sucked, then after I was already several episodes in I'm told that that friend just has shit taste.

(Yes I watched R2.)

Now tell me this, was he actually dead at the end or did he inherit his father's code?

@Prince of Seraphs

At first I thought he was dead, but C.C.'s last statement has made me suspicious. They way she moved her head made it kind of look like she was addressing the driver.

[Lady Seraphina]

It's possible she was addressing the sky, like talking to Lelouche where ever he is after death but I think they left it purposely ambiguous.

The one I really for sorry for is Lelouche's friend. He's going to have to live the rest of his life as Zero as he's supposed to be dead.