@Willy Vereb That's been done before, give everyone whatever they want. Even if it isn't overly powered, in the roleplay there are excuses, which can be reasonable, to say 'mine is better, which is why they die. If they say they are better, they are OP'
I'd rather have a stable system called a munchkin system, than an unstable system die.
Keyguy has witnessed such a thing multiple times. Wilson has been victim to it several times. I'm sure Terminal and Alfhedil have seen it enough.
I am not saying their roleplays were bad, I'm saying the players were.
Willy, if you don't like the system, please don't get involved. This whole system is experimental and was ONLY made because people HAVE to have all out wars. For one, I am extremely tired of the Nations that belittle another because of power.
@Willy Vereb That's been done before, give everyone whatever they want. Even if it isn't overly powered, in the roleplay there are excuses, which can be reasonable, to say 'mine is better, which is why they die. If they say they are better, they are OP'
I'd rather have a stable system called a munchkin system, than an unstable system die.
Keyguy has witnessed such a thing multiple times. Wilson has been victim to it several times. I'm sure Terminal and Alfhedil have seen it enough.
I am not saying their roleplays were bad, I'm saying the players were.
Willy, if you don't like the system, please don't get involved. This whole system is experimental and was ONLY made because people HAVE to have all out wars. For one, I am extremely tired of the Nations that belittle another because of power.
I rather not turn this into a poisonous debate so I only give you a few flying mention.
Nope, most of the categories are practically interchangeable. Laser IS radiation, for starters. If you have a shield which tanks these powerful lasers, you can resist nukes in space (given if they are at similar levels of power). Radiation is irrelevant compared to the levels of energies we'll be throwing at each other.
What you list under biological weapons share nothing in common (poison, radiation, heat and plasma).
And lastly EMP or ionic energy is no magic. EMP in particular is just poor man's charged particle weapon. They don't just magically shut down electronics any more than any other DEW does.
So yeah, there are many issues. Besides, the way it's worded is a blatant rock paper scissors system.
Although the way you state it would make it different but then there's no point for the weapon/defense pairings to begin with.
And nope, I still don't think powergaming ruined any of the recent Space NRPs. It was apathy. People had fun in creating their NS but they got busy and it starts a chain reaction spiraling downwards until the game turns into a graveyard void of any decent activity.
And if somebody is on a powertrip? Shoot him down. GMs could do something once in a while.
These are my last comments on the matter. In order to prevent escalation I refuse to continue this debate further.
I wish you have fun with the game. Depending on how much free time I get I may or may not take part in it.