[OOC] The Duel Tower: The first year students. (A Yu-Gi-Oh! Duel Academy Roleplay.) [Axed]

[LunarStandard]

Well, I linked to the ruling, but I'll quote it if I have to:

"If a monster Equipped with Dragunity Aklys is removed from the field and Aklys is sent to the Graveyard, you can NOT destroy a card on the field. Since the monster is no longer present, Aklys was not Equipped to a monster when it was destroyed; it was instead destroyed by game mechanics."

[Jangel13]

Look I am putting my foot down on this the card clearly says "if destroyed while equipped to a monster destroy 1 card on the field" I am following what it says on the card I am not going to relinquish my win on that ruling when I'm following what it says on the printed card

[Jangel13]

Otherwise it would say "when destroyed directly then remove one card on the field"

[Eklispe]

Ha you think Yugioh cards are worded to have their effects clear at all times? Nerd. (I jest but still)

[Scarifar]

If "Dragunity Aklys" is sent to the Graveyard since the equipped monster is destroyed, then its effect activates.If "Dragunity Aklys" and the equipped monster are destroyed simultaneously, then "Dragunity Aklys"'s effect activates.

I beg to differ from the wiki

@Jangel13

The ruling you were quoting is apparently not official, so it can't be used to argue about it.

On Lunar's side, the ruling he's quoting AND linking, I might add, has sound reasoning to back up the ruling.

[LunarStandard]

First of all, I'm not telling you to relinquish your win. I'm clearing up a ruling and nothing else.

Second of all, if we're going to follow the card text exactly, the card text very clearly says that it must be sent to the Graveyard while equipped to a monster. Well, if the monster's destroyed, then the card's no longer equipped. It's just game mechanics.

Third of all, the GM very clearly stated how the card works (which makes me wonder why he didn't pick up on it this time).

In any case, I'm just stating a ruling. I'll let Ammok decide what to do from here.

[Jangel13]

I don't care I am not going to give up my win regardless. Seriously why can't you guys let me just enjoy the fact I just won for the first time here. Statics the gm and won a favorite card in the process. I don't check up on anything you guys might use in a duel cause I trust you guys not what a wiki says

[Scarifar]

Name: Supervisor
Level: 4
Attribute: EARTH
Monster Type(s): Warrior / Tuner
Effect: Cannot be Normal Summoned/Set. If you control a face-up Gemini Monster, you can Special Summon this card.
ATK/DEF: 1500/1200

[Eklispe]

Jangel we're very specifically saying we don't really care that it happened, just that it doesn't happen again. No one wants to take anything from you.

As for the card my only complaint is that its attack seems a little high for its usefulness otherwise.

[The Red Seelie]

Name: Supervisor
Level: 4
Attribute: EARTH
Monster Type(s): Warrior
Effect: Cannot be Normal Summoned/Set. If you control a Gemini Monster, you can Special Summon this card. If you do, you can target one Gemini Monster you control; that monster is treated as an Effect Monster, and gains its effects.
ATK/DEF: 1900/800

@Scarifar

My R4NK Sense is tingling. But most of those are numbers so its restricted in that aspect. Still a Good card, strictly better super double summon. I like it.

(good combo with the Valkyrie that has the destruction effect)

In other news Still dead in the water of what to write.

[Ammokkx]

First of all, I'm not telling you to relinquish your win. I'm clearing up a ruling and nothing else.

@LunarStandard

I'm conflicted on this, actually. There's two reasons why I don't want to do it, but one reason why I do. The reason I do is: It's the second offense, it shouldn't have happened.

The two reasons why not: I'm biased since I was in the duel and lost, and I failed to pick up on it in the moment itself (which I had figured, but forgot to double check so it went over my head.)

I really want to say redo it. But I screwed up. Y'know what? @Eklispe@1Charak2@Scarifar@Satoshi Kyou@vancexentan@LunarStandard@The Irish Tree@EviiPaladin@Joshua Tamashii

What do YOU guys think I should do? Should I not make it count because Angelo should have known better and redo the thing, or let it slide again this time?

Name: Supervisor
Level: 4
Attribute: EARTH
Monster Type(s): Warrior / Tuner
Effect: Cannot be Normal Summoned/Set. If you control a Gemini Monster, you can Special Summon this card. If you do, you can target one Gemini Monster you control; that monster is treated as an Effect Monster, and gains its effects.
ATK/DEF: 1500/1200

@Scarifar

Hm. I need another opinion beside Eklispe and Charak on this one.

[Eklispe]

I don't think yall should have to redo it. Maybe throw in a rematch? Perhaps say the disks messed up and didn't catch the mistake. Win still counts, but do another duel anyway. idk

[vancexentan]

I really don't want to do another tag collaboration. Those took forever and a half. I lost both of them anyways I fine with that as long as I don't need to go through whatever that was again.

[Ammokkx]

I really don't want to do another tag collaboration. Those took forever and a half. I lost both of them anyways I fine with that as long as I don't need to go through whatever that was again.

@vancexentan

This isn't about tag collabs. It's about my duel with Angelo.

[vancexentan]

If you want to go ahead and have a re-match/Re-do then by all means do so I have no issues with it.

[The Irish Tree]

<Snipped quote by LunarStandard>

I'm conflicted on this, actually. There's two reasons why I don't want to do it, but one reason why I do. The reason I do is: It's the second offense, it shouldn't have happened.

The two reasons why not: I'm biased since I was in the duel and lost, and I failed to pick up on it in the moment itself (which I had figured, but forgot to double check so it went over my head.)

I really want to say redo it. But I screwed up. Y'know what? @Eklispe@1Charak2@Scarifar@Satoshi Kyou@vancexentan@LunarStandard@The Irish Tree@EviiPaladin@Joshua Tamashii

What do YOU guys think I should do? Should I not make it count because Angelo should have known better and redo the thing, or let it slide again this time?

<Snipped quote by Scarifar>

Hm. I need another opinion beside Eklispe and Charak on this one.

@Ammokkx

At this point all it's gonna do is waste both you, and Jangel's time. To be honest, I don't see a point. I definitely see the problem, but I don't see a reason to correct it. For the future, you just have to be more careful and maybe try and keep it in mind. I understand how confusing Dragunity Aklys is, being a fan of the archetype myself, so I'd forgive Jangel and just call it a day.

[Scarifar]

Name: Supervisor
Level: 4
Attribute: EARTH
Monster Type(s): Warrior / Tuner
Effect: Cannot be Normal Summoned/Set. If you control a Gemini Monster, you can Special Summon this card. If you do, you can target one Gemini Monster you control; that monster is treated as an Effect Monster, and gains its effects.
ATK/DEF: 1500/1200

@Scarifar

So, anyone have opinions on this card?

[Joshua Tamashii]

<Snipped quote by LunarStandard>

I'm conflicted on this, actually. There's two reasons why I don't want to do it, but one reason why I do. The reason I do is: It's the second offense, it shouldn't have happened.

The two reasons why not: I'm biased since I was in the duel and lost, and I failed to pick up on it in the moment itself (which I had figured, but forgot to double check so it went over my head.)

I really want to say redo it. But I screwed up. Y'know what? @Eklispe@1Charak2@Scarifar@Satoshi Kyou@vancexentan@LunarStandard@The Irish Tree@EviiPaladin@Joshua Tamashii

What do YOU guys think I should do? Should I not make it count because Angelo should have known better and redo the thing, or let it slide again this time?

<Snipped quote by Scarifar>

Hm. I need another opinion beside Eklispe and Charak on this one.

@Ammokkx

I agree that redoing it is a waste of time. But my philosophy to misplays is if you don't catch it, deal with the consequences.

[Eklispe]

<Snipped quote by Scarifar>

So, anyone have opinions on this card?

@Scarifar

I like the attack drop but the addition of tuner seems a bit too much to me. :<

[SillyPhilly]

@Ammokkx

Perhaps only have it last until the End Phase?