Captain, if you'd like, we can just say that Theo was shocked into silence and I can post again. Not that I'm hurrying you or anything, it's just that I know how sucky it feels when you're the one holding things up; that way, you'd have another round of posts to start composing your own. If you'd rather not, that's completely alright, it was just a thought.
Ax was always my absolute favorite character. I always found reading him thoroughly enjoyable; it's one of the reasons that I wanted to play an andalite character. I really liked Rachel, too, because she was unique from most characters I'd read as a kid. I liked Tobias, but his angsting could get on my nerves sometimes. Marco was great, Jake was usually really boring to me, and I went back and forth on Cassie. I liked her at first, but I hated how she kept up bringing moral issues that were really non-issues. That was mostly a ghost writer thing, though.
Also, I loved the Pemalites. They were really rad to me.