<Snipped quote by Fabricant451>
Right but Persona 3 also got a rhythm dancing game, 4 animated films, a spin-off Anime series and its full cast along with 4's were both in the spotlight in Persona Q. There is no universe in which that game is overlooked, not now at least. Is there a general opinion that 4 is better 3? Sort of, its not exactly unanimous, sort of like the community bitching over FF7 vs FF6.
P5 is critically acclaimed by users and critics alike, its treated like the anime Witcher 3, I'd have to scour the internet long and hard to find people bitching about it not being good cause its not like 4, thats a niche right there.
Is 4 the weakest out 3,4,5? I think so, but by like a pube hair. I guess when talking about underrated and overrated games, it just seems like nitpicking titles from the same series which are like 9.7 9.4 and 9.9 out of 10 seems kinda redundant.
Persona 3 only got a dancing game because of Persona 4's, those Persona 3 recap movies? Came out
after Persona 4's anime and was even teased in the theatrical release of Persona 4's anime movie. Every single piece of spin off media except for Trinity Soul can be followed back to Persona 4's explosive success. Persona 4 sold three times as much as Atlus expected and if it wasn't for Persona 4's runaway success then Persona 5's sales might not have been as good as they were.
Persona 5 is not treated like anime Witcher 3 (also that's a dumb comparison stop it), Persona 4 is. The argument for 4 vs 5 always boils down to personal preference, like which cast was better or which one had the weaker plot (5 for the former, 4 for the latter, natch) or people complaining that there's too much style or "Morgana won't let me leave" because they forgot all the times you were railroaded into sleeping in Persona 4 I guess.
I don't understand how you can't think Persona 4 can be overrated while also being a 9.0 game. Overrated doesn't mean bad.
But then Persona 5 has Futaba who is the worst so Persona 5 sucks now.