Best Character @HenryJonesJr's Spider-Gwen. If there's one thing I absolutely loathe about modern geek culture, it's the obsession with getting rid of established classic characters and replacing them with race- or gender-swapped proxies. I think it's generally done less out of love for a character and more to push politics I don't support, I think it causes more problems in the fandoms than it solves, and I think it brings out the worst in people on both sides of the argument. Fucking hate it. So for Henry to lean into my absolute biggest pet peeve, relegate my favorite character in all of fiction to sidekick duty, and
still win me over and make Spider-Gwen a character I genuinely look forward to reading, is a major testament to his capability as a writer to really bring a character to life.
(It should be noted that
@Sep managed to pull off this same feat as well with Iris, so I guess take that as an honorable mention)
Best Character Development @Lord Wraith's Thor. The best stories are often ones that take a while to tell, and Donald Blake's gradual but inevitable transformation into the God of Thunder has been a real treat to watch.
Best Season @Byrd Man's John Constantine. I'll be honest, when this game was first announced, I'd be lying if I said I thought we'd all be here by season's end-- we old Hypesters are notorious for dropping out as soon as we start to lose momentum. But if there's one guy who never let his momentum drop from the word 'go,' it was Byrd, plowing through the season like the goddamn Juggernaut with a fantastic set of punchy and entertaining magic-noir stories.
Best Antagonist Some really fun villains all around, including Black Tarantula, Silver Surfer, and even Victor Creel of all people, but if I've gotta pick one, it's gonna be
@Master Bruce's take on the Riddler, Edward 'Nashton.' It shouldn't really be any surprise that MB did a good job with a Gotham character, but to take a character that so often either gets dismissed as a second-rate gag villain or cranked up to ridiculous levels to drive home that he's not the Joker you guys, and make him a cunning and truly menacing threat to the Batman even while ostensibly working on the side of the law, is no mean feat.
Best Supporting Cast Again, lots of great picks to choose from, but I think I'm gonna have to go with
@Eddie Brock's Avengers. It would've been really easy to lean on having just, say, Bucky or Falcon or Black Widow palling around with Cap, but his fantastic revision of Diana Prince in a setting where someone else has already claimed the Wonder Woman mantle is pretty damn stellar.
Best World-building There really isn't any other choice but
@Master Bruce's Gotham City. There was some great work all around from everyone, but the level of depth and detail that went into creating this version of Gotham and the people in it is just kinda staggering.
Best Concept This was a very,
very close call, but I'm gonna give my vote to
@DocTachyon's Vigilante/Ghost Rider, with
@Morden Man's Fantastic Four as a very close second. When we do these universe-crossover games, there's always someone who wants to mix and match origins, and it's usually pretty obvious stuff. What if Bruce Wayne was Daredevil, what if Captain America led the Justice Society, what if Dick Grayson got bitten by the radioactive spider, etc. So to take two characters I would have never, in a million years, have thought of combining-- one of whom being a DC D-lister who I don't think anyone's ever given a damn about, the other a Marvel side character who has coasted by his entire existence solely on looking cool-- and to turn them into a well-rounded and extremely fun character is something really special. Anyone can take two concepts that are similar on the surface and mash them together into something that should be a crowd-pleaser, but Doc was able to spin straw into goddamn
gold.