[OOC] Heroes of Beacon - the Next Chapter

[Lugubrious]

When reading your recent post, Krazikk, I had visions of shoving a tiny Knight Artorias the Abysswalker into a scabbard.

[Lucius Cypher]

At some point Gren is going to need to steal this line.

[Forsythe]

I'm sorry is it just me or are maiden powers really overrated by their guardian group? I mean Amber wasn't able to take on 3 people (+ maybe Neo). Not that impressive, I think she should be afraid of the termite.

[Lucius Cypher]

Element of surprise aside, I think Amber handled herself quite well. She just had an unfortunate case of dramatic tension when she was about to take out Emerald (Not that it would have stopped Cinder if Emerald was offed then and there, probably) with an arrow to the back. Plus Qrow literally came in at the last minute, when everyone was turkered out from the fighting. Heck I'm certain even Cinder would have a hard time taking a more-or-less fresh Qrow, Maiden powers notwithstanding.

Though it really does make me start to question just how aura works. Assuming that Amber wasn't totally pooped out, you'd figure her aura would have protected her from getting shot in the back, or at least not leave her in such a weakened state. Could be explained by Cinder's arrows being funky, but I dunno. Maybe it's one of those active passives where if you aren't trying to protect yourself your aura isn't going to save you, so people can still be assassinated in their sleep or whatever.

Also who wants to get their limbs chopped off? I think Gren should start selling cybernetic parts.

[chukklehed]

I'm just going to mention, I called that it wasn't Neo doing the illusions.

Also, if you look when the explosion arrows happen, Amber's Aura falls away, leaving her vulnerable. I'm assuming it was her Maiden Powers allowing her to protect herself after that.

[Lugubrious]

Element of surprise aside, I think Amber handled herself quite well. She just had an unfortunate case of dramatic tension when she was about to take out Emerald (Not that it would have stopped Cinder if Emerald was offed then and there, probably) with an arrow to the back. Plus Qrow literally came in at the last minute, when everyone was turkered out from the fighting. Heck I'm certain even Cinder would have a hard time taking a more-or-less fresh Qrow, Maiden powers notwithstanding.

Though it really does make me start to question just how aura works. Assuming that Amber wasn't totally pooped out, you'd figure her aura would have protected her from getting shot in the back, or at least not leave her in such a weakened state. Could be explained by Cinder's arrows being funky, but I dunno. Maybe it's one of those active passives where if you aren't trying to protect yourself your aura isn't going to save you, so people can still be assassinated in their sleep or whatever.

Also who wants to get their limbs chopped off? I think Gren should start selling cybernetic parts.

@Lucius Cypher

If you watch closely the part where Cinder uses a devastating fire attack against Amber, you can see her aura break just like Mercury's did in his fight.

[Lucius Cypher]

Oui. Well then that makes more sense. Still, dramatic tension was Amber's downfall. Shoulda just flatten the place with ice knives or something, let the AoE finish off the scrappers.

[Plank Sinatra]

I'm sorry is it just me or are maiden powers really overrated by their guardian group? I mean Amber wasn't able to take on 3 people (+ maybe Neo). Not that impressive, I think she should be afraid of the termite.

@Forsythe

Mercury is worth at least a team's worth of first years. He was trained from birth by a top notch assassin to end human life with ease, and is expert in a fighting style that revolves around a pair of legs that can take an Ember Celica blast at point blank and come out no worse for wear. Emerald is a master thief who has displayed, in her only instances of combat, zero signs of wear, a talent for psych warfare, and a devastating ability at mid to long range. Even in the fights they've thrown to put the heroes at ease, they've dominated until it was convenient not to. In the one fight we've seen them go full speed on, the only reason they didn't straight up murder Coco and Yatsu - the two strongest fighters we've seen out of Beacon students - was because it was too soon in the plan.

Judging Amber by the most hardcore badasses in the show, especially after she was ready to kill one, PLUS the current candidate for Big Bad, isn't exactly fair. Even if discounting the point above about dramatic tension in a narrative.

[Ookawa]

I wanted to post today, but I'm tired and have to get up at 4 am for work... which is in about 6 hours... so definitely tomorrow.

[Forsythe]

Well yeah, but still they way Ozpin portrayed it. I expected something more... earth shattering, shall we say. But I'll nod at the experience argument. And she could have been holding back, good characters tend to do that for some reason instead of going for the kill.

[Lugubrious]

Well yeah, but still they way Ozpin portrayed it. I expected something more... earth shattering, shall we say. But I'll nod at the experience argument. And she could have been holding back, good characters tend to do that for some reason instead of going for the kill.

@Forsythe

Might the some reason be that good characters don't kill people outright?

[Forsythe]

<Snipped quote by Forsythe>

Might the some reason be that good characters don't kill people outright?

@Lugubrious

Well duh, I was just being evil myself :P

[MULTI_MEDIA_MAN]

<Snipped quote by Forsythe>

Might the some reason be that good characters don't kill people outright?

@Lugubrious

Yeah, nah. The requirements to wield Mjolnir include "Must be willing to kill" for a reason.

[chukklehed]

<Snipped quote by Lugubrious>

Yeah, nah. The requirements to wield Mjolnir include "Must be willing to kill" for a reason.

@MULTI_MEDIA_MAN

You mean Thor's Mjolnir? The requirements for that are to be "worthy" not "good"

[MULTI_MEDIA_MAN]

<Snipped quote by MULTI_MEDIA_MAN>

You mean Thor's Mjolnir? The requirements for that are to be "worthy" not "good"

@chukklehed

Word of God literally says that "Only those of sound moral character and integrity may lift Mjolnir." Sometimes you have to kill people, especially so in worlds with super-powers.

[Lugubrious]

<Snipped quote by chukklehed>

Word of God literally says that "Only those of sound moral character and integrity may lift Mjolnir." Sometimes you have to kill people, especially so in worlds with super-powers.

@MULTI_MEDIA_MAN

Batman disagrees.

[MULTI_MEDIA_MAN]

<Snipped quote by MULTI_MEDIA_MAN>

Batman disagrees.

@Lugubrious

Yes, let's trust the psychotic vigilante with family problems that make the Jackson 5 look stable by comparison.

[Lugubrious]

<Snipped quote by Lugubrious>

Yes, let's trust the psychotic vigilante with family problems that make the Jackson 5 look stable by comparison.

@MULTI_MEDIA_MAN

..You're not wrong.

[Lady Seraphina]

Yes, let's trust the psychotic vigilante with family problems that make the Jackson 5 look stable by comparison.

@MULTI_MEDIA_MAN

In Batman's first appearances in the Detective comics he was a badass mother fucker who killed who he liked and damned the consequences. Only bad guys of course but he killed a lot of people.

[Plank Sinatra]

I'm not too happy about a lotta what's going into BvS but Batfleck looks like the best character interpretation in at least two decades so I'm not gonna jump on the "he's a maniac" Batwagon

(ayyoooooo channeling my inner fiordilatte today)