"Going to Katwiz did not strike me as a sound option. Given it's a major town, and that as you said, has the possibility of being under the red stripes' control, picking Katwiz as our next destination seemed rather reckless. We have an injured person for one, which would be a liability should we end up in a fight. That said, you are also correct that looking around in the dark for where the Red Stripes' enemy may be also seems to be a fool's errand...So, why not attempt to go back to Dragon's Maw? As I've said, our mission was to bring back Paladin Thomas and his entourage. We found the group dead at their base camp, and now we have confirmation that Paladin Thomas was also dead. Why exactly are we remaining in this land rather than making our reports and awaiting further orders?"
Truth be told, Carmen did not expect someone would oppose his plan. So when Carnathia expressed her doubt, it added up to his building agitation. He felt like his devotion was being attacked. "Because I do not believe it until I see him myself," he answered, clinging to a fragile compassion to remain composed.
“I didn’t want to ask at the time because we were still recuperating, but are you saying that this Thomas person we’re looking for is dead?” asked Osric.
"That Redstripes scoundrel from the camp, said so." a scowl escaped him, and he reached for a shield hung on his back. No doubt it once belonged to Thomas himself, and he wasn't delusional enough to eliminate the worst possibility. Part of him might have already accepted this possibility but was unable to find the justification.
He looked at Carnathia searchingly. Her question demanded a justification, why not retreat to Dragon's Maw? Why were they still here?
The light from the fire camp washed on his face, there was silence for a moment, but only a few would notice another fire flickering in their Captain's eyes.
"There is still a hope that Thomas is still alive, and I don't want to abandon that hope. I can feel it. Even if he dies, I want to know why." Slowly the anger started to seep into his voice."We are more than capable of infiltrating this region. And if our concern is our wounds, then there was no better place to head to than a nearby town. It is I believe, a better option than risking weeks going back to Dragon's Maw."
The sternness in his demeanor told one important thing the Captain did not say. A zeal that turns into a determination to seek retribution. He wanted to make them pay.
"Orders aren't worth following if it means leaving people to die, Senorita Carnathia. And from whose that order you mentioned came from but from a misanthrope elf that knows nothing of our values?! Why should I follow that?! To lay down my arms and leave after they murdered my brethren?"
Carmen stared at Carnathia with a hidden disdain. The situation was heating up, but before anyone could throw another argument Osric intervened, not a moment too soon, really.
“I think before we do anything, lets at least finish patching ourselves up. Even in the fire light, I can see that apple on your head, Carmen. To take a ball to the skull like that, you’re lucky it didn’t knock your head off. That Lynx girl seems to be healing in that, um, ice block of hers. With her in that state, we’re not really going anywhere anyway until she thaws herself out. Lets give it the night and discuss it again in the morning.”
To that, Carmen nodded. He had been enduring the pain, and there was a truth that it muddled his judgment. But was it? The wound was caused by the enemy, and he embraced the pain as the fuel to plan his next move. Retreating back to his corner, Carmen was quickly on a deep thought regarding what he just said.