1 Guest viewing this page
Hidden 1 yr ago 1 yr ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 24 min ago

@Eviledd1984

A few things:

1. You forgot to include Okayasu's Perception in his Pirate Parameters.

2. His Martial Arts, how well can he cut things with his hands? Can they substitute a full-on sword or other slashing/cutting weapon? And if he already has swordmanship at a level where he can cut almost anything, what is ht purpose of having learned this particular form of fighting-style?

3. Speaking of his swordsmanship, please elaborate a bit more about in his history, as well on his master(s). Who they were and why they know the skills/techniques they do, and why they decided to take in a thieving street-urchin and teach him their rather impressive skills.

4. I'd like to know, in your history, wht Okayasu, and the man he wants vengeance on, came all the way from Umitoshi (in the far east) to the waters in the far west. Granted, this is partly my fault for not explicitly stating where in the world Prawncourt is located to begin wtih.

5. It seems you forgot something else, please have a look through the Rules again.

Once these points have been addressed, let me know and I'll go over your CS again. :)
Hidden 1 yr ago Post by Eviledd1984
Raw
Avatar of Eviledd1984

Eviledd1984 Narn Liberator

Member Seen 37 min ago

@Xaltwind

I have made some edits to my character sheet, so just let me know if I need to make any further improvements. I was thinking of the man to be from the far away that Okuyasu's father had crossed. But I can add in a bit of detail on that if you like.
Hidden 1 yr ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 24 min ago

@Eviledd1984

Good, good. Everything seems to be in order. Still a bit shaky on why the man Okayasu wants to kill came all the way to the west, but I suppose some mysteries can be left for the IC:

Accepted, welcome aboard. Arrh~
Hidden 1 yr ago Post by Eviledd1984
Raw
Avatar of Eviledd1984

Eviledd1984 Narn Liberator

Member Seen 37 min ago

@Xaltwind

I don't mind adding the reason the man wanted to kill Okuyasu's dad in the character sheet.
Hidden 1 yr ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 24 min ago

Is fine, is fine.
You can share the tale with all the other crew over some drinks abd bread, and then tell tales of other times you had drinks and bread.
1x Like Like
Hidden 1 yr ago 1 yr ago Post by LongSwordMain
Raw
Avatar of LongSwordMain

LongSwordMain Tripping you up since 3U

Member Seen 12 mos ago


Hidden 1 yr ago 1 yr ago Post by Expendable
Raw
Avatar of Expendable

Expendable The Certifiable

Member Seen 6 hrs ago

Since we can have up to two characters and half-elves were okay in the Interest thread, here are my two offerings. I hope they're acceptable?





The Prince is just a bored dandy out to have a little fun, while the cabin boy has a ton of story hooks ready to exploit. There's also the situation comedy of him being unware that his cabin boy isn't a boy, and despite appearances, she is actually older and more experienced than him. Shades Haruhi of Ouran High School Host Club and Sebastian of Black Butler. Or would she be more like Radar from MASH?
Hidden 1 yr ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 24 min ago

@LongSwordMain
Aw, she looks like a cute lass.
But, you seem to have forgotten some things from the CS template. I urge you to look through it again. Especially in the Appearance and Pirate Parameters-parts

@Expendable
The Prince has very high stats, like, really high. And some of the stats don't make much sense, considering his background and life-style. Considering he ca't figure out that his own cabin boy is a female, I'm surprised his Wits and his Perception aren't way lower. Also, he doesn't seem to have gone through any rigorous training or had a particularly hard life, so his Strength being as high as it is also doesn't make much sense.

However, if those are the stats you want, then that's fine. I'm just giving you my opinion on them as the GM.

As for your skills, I'd prefer it if you actually used real descriptions to detail how wlel he does what, rather than a numeric-system which I have no idea how to, or knowledge of, to properly measure.

The Cabin "Boy" has a lot of history and drama, but a lot of it is very vague and seems to assume the reader knows the name-dropped characters, places and titles of the things and people mentioned... Which is fine, but it feels a bit like starting to read a book at the very middle and having names and locations thrown at you, without any prior info about them.

Both characters are otherwise fully acceptable, but again, I'd like it if you edited the Skills-part of both of them first.
Hidden 1 yr ago 1 yr ago Post by Expendable
Raw
Avatar of Expendable

Expendable The Certifiable

Member Seen 6 hrs ago

@Expendable
The Prince has very high stats, like, really high. And some of the stats don't make much sense, considering his background and life-style. Considering he ca't figure out that his own cabin boy is a female, I'm surprised his Wits and his Perception aren't way lower. Also, he doesn't seem to have gone through any rigorous training or had a particularly hard life, so his Strength being as high as it is also doesn't make much sense.

However, if those are the stats you want, then that's fine. I'm just giving you my opinion on them as the GM.

As for your skills, I'd prefer it if you actually used real descriptions to detail how well he does what, rather than a numeric-system which I have no idea how to, or knowledge of, to properly measure.

The Cabin "Boy" has a lot of history and drama, but a lot of it is very vague and seems to assume the reader knows the name-dropped characters, places and titles of the things and people mentioned... Which is fine, but it feels a bit like starting to read a book at the very middle and having names and locations thrown at you, without any prior info about them.

Both characters are otherwise fully acceptable, but again, I'd like it if you edited the Skills-part of both of them first.


First paragraph establishes his extensive training, but I've no problem dumbing down Prince Dunderhead further. Are these stats and skill descriptions more to your liking? I'm using your pirate parameters scale to give a quick read of their skill levels - a B in navigation, for example.

And really it's not entirely his fault for not realizing Aywin's a girl. She was mal-nourished from prison, and food aboard navy ships isn't that much better, honestly. Lots of protein and some carbs, good for muscle mass but little else. And I do mean little. Despite her age and thanks to her elven blood, she looks like a skinny, underdeveloped teenager.

As far as titles go, a marquis is a high ranking noble, just below a duke. Aywin's uncle, the judge, is a government official who works under him, top third. Or at least did.

Sorry about the names. Aywin ought to know her family. Really they're hooks for future information.

As far as the rest go, sorry it's vague but I'm just putting in the basic important details, they're story hooks for later. Like if the captain goes digging through the cabin boy's sea bag and finds her medal. I know it's tied to the blockade of Mylmashys and the fireships, something the captain might have heard of.
Hidden 1 yr ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 24 min ago

I suppose I should clarify what the stats actually stand for, or what they correspond to.
-----
S = Superb, uncanny, the peak of physical limitations.

A = Exceptional, very good, very high.

B = Good, high, noteworthy

C = Above average, decent, fine

D = Below average, alright, okay, fair, meh

E = Poor, bad, low, lacking

F = Terrible, very low, very poor, pitiful
-----
So, having something like 'A' rank in Strength woud put you on the level of something like a body-builder or someone who frequently and often works out and is JACKED as PHUCK.

Anyway, the edits and revisions are fine and good, so both of them are accepted. Now adding to characters tab.
Hidden 1 yr ago 1 yr ago Post by Crowvette
Raw
Avatar of Crowvette

Crowvette Shock Unlocker

Member Seen 2 days ago

Wanted to get some thoughts on it, if I need more detail or anything.

1x Laugh Laugh
Hidden 1 yr ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 24 min ago

I like Cass, she sounds fun. :)

You probably should take another look at the Rules though, before I can approve her~
1x Thank Thank
Hidden 1 yr ago Post by Zapdos
Raw
Avatar of Zapdos

Zapdos Electric Pokemon

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

I just wanted to let you know that I can't think of a character that would completely fit the tone of your RP, so I will be withdrawing from this. Good luck with your RP!
1x Thank Thank
Hidden 1 yr ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 24 min ago

@Zapdos
I'm sorry to hear that, but thank you for letting me know. I wish you the best of luck in whichever other Rps you may join in the future.
1x Like Like
Hidden 1 yr ago Post by Crowvette
Raw
Avatar of Crowvette

Crowvette Shock Unlocker

Member Seen 2 days ago

I like Cass, she sounds fun. :)

You probably should take another look at the Rules though, before I can approve her~


Oh yeah, fixed that one up.
Hidden 1 yr ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 24 min ago

Splendifirous!
Accepted~
Hidden 1 yr ago Post by Silverstein
Raw
Avatar of Silverstein

Silverstein Salt-Free Wolf

Member Seen 15 hrs ago

@Xaltwind
Heya, is this still open? I wanna join your crew if possible.

I was thinking of a priest turned pirate who cons brings people to salvation, spread the word of the 'seagod' and relieves them the burden of their worldly possession.
Hidden 1 yr ago Post by Expendable
Raw
Avatar of Expendable

Expendable The Certifiable

Member Seen 6 hrs ago

@Xaltwind
Heya, is this still open? I wanna join your crew if possible.

I was thinking of a priest turned pirate who cons brings people to salvation, spread the word of the 'seagod' and relieves them the burden of their worldly possession.


I don't know for sure, but the Apply flag is still flying. Just make sure you read all the rules.

Hidden 1 yr ago Post by sly13
Raw
Avatar of sly13

sly13

Member Seen 2 mos ago

This might be interesting. I would be possibly interested in playing the ships doctor or a surgeon type character if that would fit. still trying to work out all the details.
Hidden 1 yr ago 1 yr ago Post by Xaltwind
Raw
GM
Avatar of Xaltwind

Xaltwind Disgruntled Dragonfly

Member Seen 24 min ago

@Silverstein, @sly13
I appreciate the interest, but at this time, we're waitingon word from the people on the Reservation3--list, the post is just below the first OOC post. Until the people on that list either finish their CS'es or announce they no longer want to join, I'm afraid I can't accept new applicants, as I promised that people who spoke up in the interest check would get priority.

If the remaining people resign their interest though, you're both more than welcome to apply!
↑ Top
1 Guest viewing this page
© 2007-2024
BBCode Cheatsheet