Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by KoL
Raw
Avatar of KoL

KoL Knight of Lorelei

Member Seen 26 days ago

I finished my character. Just letting you know.
Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by Dezuel
Raw
Avatar of Dezuel

Dezuel Broke out of limbo

Member Seen 8 hrs ago

I have removed the WIP from my character as I've finished the biography section on it, adjusted his age and added some minor things.
Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by Vertigo
Raw
Avatar of Vertigo

Vertigo watchful

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

Will try to get a CS in on time before the deadline; if not, I'll remain as a spectator instead!

Just to clarify, the 12 AM deadline on Friday--- does that mean midday or midnight? I've seen AM/PM used both ways. We use a 24 hour clock here, so I'm never sure which is which.
Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by Carlyle
Raw
GM
Avatar of Carlyle

Carlyle 満潮

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

Will try to get a CS in on time before the deadline; if not, I'll remain as a spectator instead!

Just to clarify, the 12 AM deadline on Friday--- does that mean midday or midnight? I've seen AM/PM used both ways. We use a 24 hour clock here, so I'm never sure which is which.


12AM CST means midnight on Friday CST.
1x Thank Thank
Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by Carlyle
Raw
GM
Avatar of Carlyle

Carlyle 満潮

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

Reviews will begin this weekend, so if you are still out there with a WIP, please try to get them finished before 12:00AM CST tomorrow!
1x Thank Thank
Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by Carlyle
Raw
GM
Avatar of Carlyle

Carlyle 満潮

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

Reviews are written in red underneath each respective CS. I've tried to note any concerns I had reading each CS, and if you need elaboration, just ask. I will address those that I will chose from the applied CSes later this upcoming week.


As I see it now, I do not see any qualms I may have with the character sheet. Unless you change anything in the future, the character sheet should be good to go if it is accepted.


I like the character archetype, but I do have one issue. Zander was a "target of interest for a humanitarian organization known as the Millennium Group," but why did they chose him instead of some other orphan? You specify that he was the only one with magical aptitude, but from what I understand, this was after the Millennium Group picked him and various other orphans, correct?


I have a number of questions regarding your character sheet. Firstly, I'm curious about Selo. What exactly happened to it? You state that the citizens of the planet would face extinction, but what happened to the planet after the creation of the worldship? Additionally, if the people of Jotunheim had the scientific prowess to build a massive worldship, provided with power from its own sun as it drifts throughout the Neutral Rim, why could they not repair the damage caused to their planet? Mother Nature is a powerful force to deal with, but if the people of Selo could build a worldship, I have a feeling they could repair their planet.

Later on in the section regarding Jotunheim, you also contradict yourself. "Every citizens are always respectful and loving towards others, even if their ideals and opinions are different," but then you go on to state that those of lower intelligence are usually looked down upon, even if subtle.

As a final note, you state that An lost all muscle control in his legs, and he struggles to move his torso, being severely weakened. With three dots in strength, I feel this does not correlate with his disability. Perhaps move some points to charisma, since An speaks with politeness (outside those he considers idiots, to which he doesn't speak at all).



To be honest, this feels like a rough work-in-progress. Some sections aren't filled in/left blank, and the format is not uniform, as everything after the gender section, the headers for each section are different. Your background is both a mix of a background and appearance, which needs to be sorted out. As a final note, I would request that you try to expand your MAID some more. The section feels empty and basic compared to others.


My main concern is that the background needs to be fluffed out more. The only information I see is that Yuuno is from Tamanom, and that she had a knack for magitek so she was invited to the Asterisk. Other than that, I don't really see any other issues of note.



I think Tobal would be better fit for the Solaris Accord or the Neutral Rim rather than the People's Union. I tried to base the Union along the lines of the various types of communism, and I feel an entertainment planet won't mesh well with the Union. Otherwise, she's quite the odd one that would be interesting to see a part of the group if accepted.



So many pictures making for a lengthy CS. Good thing I'm on a PC rather than mobile.

Anyway, I don't see any real issue with the CS. My only concern is that you have Luka residing on her yacht, rather than the Asterisk itself. This may be detrimental for character interaction.




I'm not sure how well Nep would preform in combat. You say Lina can use Nep to hack things, but how does this work? Does it mean, for instance, hacking into doors, or hacking MAIDs? The latter is unlikely. Additionally, using other gadgets (such as Lina's pistol or exoskeleton) alongside the MAID is against the rules on the Asterisk.

EDIT: App complete and ready for review.



I don't doubt that there are people that are transexual or of the trap sterotype throughout the universe, but I'm going to have to say a hard no to the MAID concept you have. I doubt someone would be so willing to throw away such an old MAID (since MAIDs are highly prized throughout the universe). Additionally, while you have the concept that MAIDs should be rudimentary, with Jaelyn's MAID appearing as headphones, it is extremely complex for a MAID to have a full-on effect on someone's body, especially for so long.
Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by Dezuel
Raw
Avatar of Dezuel

Dezuel Broke out of limbo

Member Seen 8 hrs ago

Altered.
Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by Vertigo
Raw
Avatar of Vertigo

Vertigo watchful

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

Just wanted to give a heads up that I'm about halfway done with my CS (it's nearly 4 AM where I am, but I'm determined to get this done before sleep).
Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by mickilennial
Raw
Avatar of mickilennial

mickilennial The Elder Fae

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

Just wanted to give a heads up that I'm about halfway done with my CS (it's nearly 4 AM where I am, but I'm determined to get this done before sleep).

I believe in you.
1x Thank Thank
Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by Sloth
Raw
Avatar of Sloth

Sloth The Potato Salad of People

Member Seen 2 mos ago

Top level Discord reference.
1x Like Like
Hidden 6 yrs ago 6 yrs ago Post by Vertigo
Raw
Avatar of Vertigo

Vertigo watchful

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by KoL
Raw
Avatar of KoL

KoL Knight of Lorelei

Member Seen 26 days ago

@Sola

Are we suppose to go into action with one item and nothing else? There was nowhere in the description mentioning that so, I came to believe that items that should be common sense in any advanced tech setting would be ok.

Also, nowhere on the M.A.I.D.'s description is it said that they need to be something usable in combat or a weapon. I was just trying to make a device that could really earn the name of assistant and be more utilitarian than the destructive. Also, no, it wouldn't be for hacking other M.A.I.D.'s, perhaps disrupt or disable them temporarily but even that's not the original intent

Anyway, if those alterations really need to be made, despite nothing on on the opening post mentioning those facts, I'll have to think about it (and probably take my leave) since I don't know if I would like to change this character both because I like her the way she's and won't be able to come up with something new in the upcoming week thanks to IRL stuff.
Hidden 6 yrs ago 6 yrs ago Post by Darth Shadow
Raw
Avatar of Darth Shadow

Darth Shadow Watching you from afar...

Member Seen 6 yrs ago


Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by Carlyle
Raw
GM
Avatar of Carlyle

Carlyle 満潮

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

@Sola

Are we suppose to go into action with one item and nothing else? There was nowhere in the description mentioning that so, I came to believe that items that should be common sense in any advanced tech setting would be ok.

Also, nowhere on the M.A.I.D.'s description is it said that they need to be something usable in combat or a weapon. I was just trying to make a device that could really earn the name of assistant and be more utilitarian than the destructive. Also, no, it wouldn't be for hacking other M.A.I.D.'s, perhaps disrupt or disable them temporarily but even that's not the original intent

Anyway, if those alterations really need to be made, despite nothing on on the opening post mentioning those facts, I'll have to think about it (and probably take my leave) since I don't know if I would like to change this character both because I like her the way she's and won't be able to come up with something new in the upcoming week thanks to IRL stuff.


Firstly, I stated that people should PM me if they had concerns or questions. If you weren't sure, you could've PM'd me (or said something here). In fact, someone did PM me their question about exactly what you had assumed.

Secondly, I did say "the Asterisk would serve as a way for each respective government to duel each other without the destructive power of a full-scale war." This RP is supposed to be shonen-esque, and the source material that inspired this roleplay all have combat situations. I did not directly say MAIDs should be a weapon to be used in combat, but the above statements should've left enough to be inferred that they were to be used during combat, just like everyone else had thought.

That being said, if you do intend to leave, then I hope you find luck elsewhere.
Hidden 6 yrs ago 6 yrs ago Post by mickilennial
Raw
Avatar of mickilennial

mickilennial The Elder Fae

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

I know I'm just a player, but I think Sola’s transparency on his influences for this RP as well as the concepts provided through some flavorful gifs was fine enough indication that this was a battle academy anime type roleplay. I’m not sure how that was misunderstood especially considering it is downright implied with the whole "you battle other students with MAIDs to solve interstellar disputes and wars" thing.

Edit: Oof Ninja'd by the GM.
Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by TheWendil
Raw
Avatar of TheWendil

TheWendil The Wendil-Sama™ / ಠ_ಠ

Member Seen 3 days ago

Firstly, I stated that people should PM me if they had concerns or questions. If you weren't sure, you could've PM'd me (or said something here). In fact, someone did PM me their question about exactly what you had assumed.


Personally, I'm not really a fan of this. While it's fine to PM misunderstandings and questions, the OP shouldn't be so vague as to be unsure of what to even ask. For my character as an example, I'm not sure if you want an entire detailed description of the planet she was living on or just more substance for her background on that planet. Nothing wrong with clarifying things we're not sure of, mind you; just not my cup of tea when it seems vague.

I think given Sola’s transparency on his influences for this RP as well as the concepts provided through some flavorful gifs was fine enough indication that this was a battle academy anime type roleplay. I’m not sure how that was misunderstood especially considering it is downright implied with the whole "you battle other students with MAIDs to solve interstellar disputes and wars" thing.


True enough, though I think KoL's issue is less with misunderstanding the RP's purpose and more wanting to make a non-standard and unique MAID. I actually thought this would be more leaning to the slice-of-life aspect since we're all just students trying to learn.

In any case @Sola, if KoL leaves I probably will as well since they're my lifeline and whatnot in things.
Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by mickilennial
Raw
Avatar of mickilennial

mickilennial The Elder Fae

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

Personally, I'm not really a fan of this. While it's fine to PM misunderstandings and questions, the OP shouldn't be so vague as to be unsure of what to even ask. For my character as an example, I'm not sure if you want an entire detailed description of the planet she was living on or just more substance for her background on that planet. Nothing wrong with clarifying things we're not sure of, mind you; just not my cup of tea when it seems vague.

True enough, though I think KoL's issue is less with misunderstanding the RP's purpose and more wanting to make a non-standard and unique MAID. I actually thought this would be more leaning to the slice-of-life aspect since we're all just students trying to learn.

In any case @Sola, if KoL leaves I probably will as well since they're my lifeline and whatnot in things.

Best wishes and all that.

Though, I’d like to say that I really do think the OP wasn’t completely vague and where it was I kind of nudged Sola to re-evaluate some issues I had with it (it was my suggestion to have us focus on first year students, for instance). For the most part everyone else communicated their questions and misconceptions with little issue and IDK got the gist of what Sola wanted to do with this RP. I hope you guys have fun on greener pastures and all that, but I think this could have been avoided with some smart questions and a re-reading of the material provided.

Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by TheWendil
Raw
Avatar of TheWendil

TheWendil The Wendil-Sama™ / ಠ_ಠ

Member Seen 3 days ago

Everyone knows reading is for squares.
1x Laugh Laugh
Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by KoL
Raw
Avatar of KoL

KoL Knight of Lorelei

Member Seen 26 days ago

<Snipped quote by KoL>

Firstly, I stated that people should PM me if they had concerns or questions. If you weren't sure, you could've PM'd me (or said something here). In fact, someone did PM me their question about exactly what you had assumed.

Secondly, I did say "the Asterisk would serve as a way for each respective government to duel each other without the destructive power of a full-scale war." This RP is supposed to be shonen-esque, and the source material that inspired this roleplay all have combat situations. I did not directly say MAIDs should be a weapon to be used in combat, but the above statements should've left enough to be inferred that they were to be used during combat, just like everyone else had thought.

That being said, if you do intend to leave, then I hope you find luck elsewhere.


Well, I didn't PM any doubts because I didn't have any regarding those issues. You can see that I understood the inspiration for this.

On these shonen stories you can always find some non standard characters (generally the kind of side character I hoped to emulate instead of another MC-esque one) kinda mine so why would I have any doubts when the OP didn't state otherwise? You see? I was working of what we were granted, there was no reason to doubt anything.

Anyway, considering the limitations of what MAIDs can do and with no extra hear allowed, I can't really see a way to fix my character and keep the spirit of what I wanted to do.

I understand if she can't but I'll have to leave since I was squeezing time for this already.
Hidden 6 yrs ago Post by Carlyle
Raw
GM
Avatar of Carlyle

Carlyle 満潮

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

@Inkarnate@Sloth@Conscripts@ERode@Feyblue@Vertigo@Darth Shadow

I know you all have been waiting for me to make my final decision, so allow me to say, welcome to Hoshizora! To everyone else that did not make the cut, there's always next time if we happen to have a recruitment drive.
2x Thank Thank
↑ Top
© 2007-2024
BBCode Cheatsheet