@1Charak2: Hoo boy. Uh...
You probably watched the Voice of Saint Quartz video on the whole 'beating Gil' thing, I assume? Because, well... I don't think Abby's at that level of strength, per se. While fully unleashing an Elder God is just really bad for humanity in general, Abby (in base form, at least) isn't actively trying to screw over the world and would likely be limited to 5head beams and light tentacles. Her NP, while problematic in that it can target and mindscrew anyone at will, is also restrained by her even in Outer form.
Like, just look at how Salem plays out. Our Servants take damage from being exposed, but they're not OUT of the fight 100%.
Also, getting her to Outer form requires very specific triggers that cause her to go off the deep end, and if you're deliberately invoking those on your end, you have a problem on your hands.
In regards to the Gil problem, well... In this scenario where every Servant is
likely registered in some sort of database post-summon and he has access to that info disregarding Clairvoyance, she doesn't have the proposed advantage to pull a Shadow on him. Also, like, he's got better things to do than bully a little girl.
So, like, she's fine?
Hokusai is far less OP since he just got octopus'd, and it's not like Ooi is any level of broken. She just paints stuff. Not like she goes throwing insanity around like candy or anything.
Angra... Well, since there's no Grail to taint, per se, Angra would be fine? Ritual is inherently the same, just different circumstances leading to weird shit, so yeah.
Dantes is also fine, honestly? He's got good stats across the board and his NPs are super speed, parameter concealment (which isn't helpful in a place where everyone can know everything) plus super fire, and a weird BatCon + parameter boosts, but he's nothing game breaking? We have a lot of people who can match him in that category.
Now for the extra list...
Nobu can benefit from more Mystery, but she's not impossible to take down. It's a matter of dealing with Papiyas that the problem, and she's just a 'hard counter' type of Servant that excels in a good matchup. Acceptable.
Ozy plops down his RM and stalls it out. Also he has the same ego problem as Gil, so don't expect him to actively fight. Or use his boat in any meaningful way other than the occasional laser.
You deserve suffering for suggesting Solomon. That's the only one I'm 100% denying.
@TheFake: Master's accepted, but Lugh's NP seems a bit UP for an A rank NP.
@Raineh Daze: Master accepted.
In any case... Yeah, I'd like people to pair up. Ideally. Since we have an odd setup, not everyone needs to make a Master per se (you can use an NPC to link up to a Servant if you'd wish or even self-pair), but I'd highly recommend it.
Melt
ideally needs a new Master, and Mr. Normal also needs one to be obtained in the future.
Double reminder: If you make a Master, you're okayed for a second Servant. Just saying.
Member
Izurich
Raineh Daze
The Otter
Urizen
Zapdos
DracoLunaris
Enzayne
FunnierPrez
Lildear18